Utah, national school superintendents optimistic about Common Core

Published: Saturday, July 12 2014 3:50 p.m. MDT

Melissa Grieshober, a third-grade teacher at Silver Lake Elementary School in Middletown, Del., teaches a math lesson Tuesday, Oct. 1, 2013. Silver Lake Elementary School has begun implementing the national Common Core State Standards for academics.

Steve Ruark, Associated Press

Enlarge photo»

SALT LAKE CITY — A majority of the nation's school district superintendents believe the Common Core State Standards are appropriately challenging and will improve education, according to a recent survey.

Two-thirds of the 1,800 school superintendents who participated in the survey, conducted by Gallup and Education Week and released last week, responded that the standards would improve education in their community.

Another 22 percent responded that the core would have no effect, and 7 percent believed adoption of the Common Core would adversely affect education.

The survey also questioned superintendents on the degree that most students would be challenged by the new standards, with two-thirds responding that the Common Core is "just about right," 14 percent responding that the standards are too challenging and 5 percent saying the standards are not challenging enough.

In Utah, opinions remain divided on the controversial standards. But many of the state's district superintendents are optimistic about the effect the Common Core will have in schools.

"We’ll see as time goes on, but my anticipation with the implementation of the Utah Core (which includes the Common Core) is that there will be a greater focus, a greater depth, a greater application, greater problem solving and intent of learning outcomes for students," Alpine School District Superintendent Vernon Henshaw said.

The Common Core is a series of English and mathematics benchmarks that outline the minimum skills a student is expected to master at each grade level. They have been adopted by all but six states, but the transition to new standards has created challenges in some parts of the country, resulting in angst from parents and educators.

Among the common criticisms is that the shift in math from rote memorization to rational problem solving and analysis has resulted in complex and confusing coursework that baffles both students and their parents.

But Ogden School District Superintendent Brad Smith said that is evidence of the increased rigor of the core, which expects students to not only apply the appropriate formula to a math problem but also understand the mathematical concepts behind those formulas.

"They're a huge step up from where we've been," he said. "A huge step up."

The Common Core was developed by identifying the skills students need to master to be prepared for college coursework and working backwards to draft standards from high school graduation to the early grades of elementary school.

Smith said that style of back-mapping is critical to changing education outcomes in the country and hadn't been attempted on a large scale prior to the Common Core.

"Our aspiration is not that our students are prepared for college entry, it’s that they’re prepared for college," he said. "The Core to me represents a reasonable, good-faith basis to try to accomplish that."

But Smith added that while he believes standards-based education is essential to improvement and that the Common Core is appropriately challenging, the new standards are not the only method that can be used to reform education.

He said many states have seen successes prior to and outside of the Core, but critics have largely focussed on attacking the new standards without offering alternatives.

"I think Common Core foes pretend that advocates of standards-based education believe the Common Core is some kind of magic talisman that will just automatically fix everything, and I don’t think anyone thinks that," he said. "I certainly don’t think that."

Try out the new DeseretNews.com design!
try beta learn more
Get The Deseret News Everywhere