Division among the 11 UTOPIA cities could threaten utility fee proposal

Published: Friday, June 27 2014 6:10 p.m. MDT

The UTOPIA board will meet next week to review options following a roughly even split between member cities on whether to pursue a controversial utility service model.

Scott G Winterton, Deseret News

Enlarge photo»

WEST VALLEY CITY — The 11 member cities of the UTOPIA fiber optic network are almost evenly split on a controversial proposal to offer Internet services as a mandatory utility, once again making the future of the embattled network uncertain.

Adam Cowie, Lindon city administrator and third vice chairman of the UTOPIA board, said board members will meet Monday to discuss their options and vote on next steps.

But it is not yet known if the division among cities will result in two separate UTOPIA partnerships, require residents to pay more in monthly fees or if the utility service model remains a viable option without an 11-city customer base.

"The question then is, is there enough support for moving forward?" Cowie said. "This is a complicated issue, and it has been a real challenge for everyone to see a clear direction on every single issue and outcome until we get further down the road."

At issue is a proposal by Australia-based Macquarie Capitol Group to assume management of the Utah Telecommunications Open Infrastructure Agency, which was created more than a decade ago amid promises of ubiquitous high-speed Internet access but has been plagued by ballooning debt, incomplete construction, low subscription rates and revenue shortfalls.

Macquarie has offered to complete the build-out of the network to all 160,000 addresses — realizing the original promise of universal access — and guarantee basic Internet service to all residents, in exchange for a monthly utility fee of initially $18 to $20 from each household for the next 30 years.

Municipal leaders in the 11 member cities were given a deadline of June 27 to either reject the deal or agree to proceed to the second of several milestones.

The city councils of Layton, West Valley City, Midvale, Brigham City, Tremonton and Perry agreed to Macquarie's terms while Centerville, Lindon, Murray, Orem and Payson rejected the proposal.

Cowie said board members have not yet heard updated figures from Macquarie, but he suspects the exit of five member cities will affect components of the proposed deal.

"That’s going to change the utility rate and some of these cities are going to need to evaluate whether it’s worth moving forward," he said.

One group watching the ongoing discussions is the Utah Taxpayers Association, which launched a petition and website at uNOpia.org and questioned the legal authority of city leaders to levy a citywide fee for telecommunication services that residents may or may not use.

Royce Van Tassell, vice president of the Utah Taxpayers Association, said the exit of five member cities has significantly changed the math of the Macquarie proposal, particularly considering that cities with larger construction needs have remained.

"From the perspective of Macquarie, having a Lindon or a Centerville in, where there isn’t nearly as much investment necessary, makes the deal financially more attractive," he said. "It’s unclear whether or not they have the critical mass necessary to move forward with this deal and we look forward to finding out what their next decision will be."

He said it's premature to speculate on what Macquarie will do, but the initial terms of the proposal were based on the potential of 160,000 addresses being connected to the network.

"It does seem that Macquarie and UTOPIA were hoping to take advantage of economies of scale," he said. "With so many cities opting out, those economies of scale aren’t nearly as available."

The lead-up to the June 27 deadline was met with considerable public interest, as cities hosted council meetings, open houses and public forums and in many cases launched surveys to solicit feedback from residents.

Try out the new DeseretNews.com design!
try beta learn more
Get The Deseret News Everywhere