'Maleficent': The feminist retelling of a Disney villain
Disney Enterprises, Inc., Greg Williams, Associated Press
In Disney’s pantheon of evil stepmothers and female deviants, Maleficent has always stood apart.
Her popularity is undeniable. Fifty-five years after “Sleeping Beauty,” she ranks second only to Scar of “The Lion King” in about.com’s ranking of the greatest Disney villains, and trailed behind the Wicked Queen from “Snow White” in MovieFone’s recent list.
Now, Disney offers “Maleficent” as a recasting of its fabled anti-heroine in a continuation of its slow shift away from its familiar princess formula. That's a victory for women, said Jacquelyn Aluotto, founder of gender equality nonprofits Real Beauty Real Women and Break the Cycle.
"I think it's a refreshing and interesting take because women are so many different things. She's an outcast," Aluotto said. "I'm really hoping that Disney will go ahead and create that bold character. As we get into a different age, women are going to demand it."
Same character, feminist take?
Without spoiling the new film, the reworking of Maleficent isn’t that of a simple cut-and-dried fairy-tale antagonist. At its center lies a conflicted, deeply troubled woman (played by Angelina Jolie) who is far from perfect, rather than an inexplicably vicious, baby-cursing witch. That's quite a departure from Disney's more familiar formula where a young princess is undermined by an older, sometimes ugly, almost always single, malevolent woman, only to be rescued (either literally, through marriage or both) by the man/prince of her dreams.
"It's a complete departure from the pretty princess getting rescued. There is no salvation coming at the hands of a man," PBS "Just Seen It" critic Lisa Johnson Mandell said after seeing the film. "Maleficent is heinously violated by the man she loved. The men are not the hero in this thing."
More than many Disney evildoers, Maleficent offers Disney perhaps its most compelling chance at a reboot because of the key differences between her and many of her contemporaries. It’s the mystery surrounding her actions that offers her the depth others like her lack.
"She's a bit wry without being whimsical," Mandell said. "She has a dark, humorous side."
Even in the classic motif of the now-clichéd Disney villainess, Maleficent is unusual. With the exception of The Wicked Queen, she’s one of the only female villains in the pre-Pixar days of Disney who was physically beautiful. Unlike her classic peers who were specifically motivated (The Wicked Queen and Cruella de Vil both hung their hats on homicidal vanity; Ursula from “The Little Mermaid” and Cinderella’s stepmother ran on toxic jealousy), Maleficent doesn’t seem to be out for power or to be the fairest of them all. Rather, she’s just plain angry.
While her reasons for cursing an infant to a teenage death were unclear at best in the 1959 original film, Maleficent seems put out over not being invited to baby Aurora’s royal christening — angry enough to wait 16 years for her curse to take effect, imprison the betrothed prince and try to kill him by becoming a dragon just to get her nebulous point across. There must be some sort of history there, which is what producer Joe Roth aims to answer with the new film, told from the Mistress of Evil’s perspective.
“This movie is about a character we’ve only known as hard-hearted, and our story answers the question ‘Why?’ I’d like audiences to feel like they’ve entered a world they’ve never seen before with ‘Maleficent,’ and I hope they come away feeling like no one is beyond redemption,” Roth said in a promotional interview for Disney.
A new direction
The film is the latest in what seems to be Disney’s investment in stories and female characters whose circumstances are more gray than black and white.
- First-timers and veterans among thousands to...
- Twila Van Leer: Wow! I'm part of history, too
- Wright Words: What I learned on a trail near...
- Motherhood Matters: 3 keys to a great family...
- Is this TV show a 'game changer for people...
- 4 tips for planning a successful family hike
- Linda & Richard Eyre: Top parenting ideas,...
- Simple cheese and chive baguettes dress up...
- Amy Iverson: Showing kids how to make... 6
- Wright Words: What I learned on a trail... 4
- First-timers and veterans among... 2
- The Clean Cut: 91-year-old widow... 2
- Tiffany Gee Lewis: Lessons from sending... 2
- Twila Van Leer: Wow! I'm part of... 1
- Heart-pounding 'Jason Bourne' makes the... 1
- Websites allow viewers, parents to... 1