Frank Pignanelli & LaVarr Webb: Why are some big controversies a non-issue in election year?
Jeffrey D. Allred, Deseret News
Politics can indeed be bizarre. Big controversies and hot topics sometimes capture the attention of the public but, to everyone’s surprise, fizzle as election year issues. As Utah politics exits the convention phase and enters the primary election season, we explore these unusual dynamics.
Serious allegations and scandal swirled around the Attorney General’s Office under its former leadership. Indictments and criminal charges are still possible. So why is the Swallow debacle a non-issue so far in this election year?
Pignanelli: “Revenge is a much more punctual paymaster than gratitude.” — Charles Caleb Colton
Republicans being Republicans, it won't happen. But every GOP candidate should send thank-you notes and flowers to House Speaker Rebecca Lockhart, former Lt. Gov. Greg Bell , Gov. Gary Herbert and legislative leadership for initiating and completing an aggressive investigation into the allegations against Swallow. The final report from the Lieutenant Governor's Office was well-crafted and pushed Swallow to resignation. The House Investigation Committee, impeccably led by Rep. Jim Dunnigan, was thorough and nonpartisan (i.e. no minority report challenging conclusions). Also, legislative Democrats deserve credit for responsibly asking important questions but allowing the process to move forward.
Political observers across the country are dumbfounded that local Republicans are not suffering smear tactics by Democrats on this topic. Activists are suggesting campaigns against GOP incumbents scream about “Culture of Corruption," "Atmosphere of Arrogance" and other such spin perfected by Newt Gingrich. But Utah officials behaved like typical Utahns and did what needed to be done — outing the misconduct and passing ethics reform legislation. Therefore, blaming Republicans who were unaware of the antics surrounding the former attorneys general is pointless and the election discourse is more civil. Doing the right thing can pay dividends.
Webb: Democratic opportunists can’t get traction on this matter because Republicans dealt with it quickly and forthrightly. Republicans were as outraged as Democrats. They aggressively investigated, tightened some laws, and made no attempt to sweep it under a rug. Newly appointed Attorney General Sean Reyes has no taint of scandal (in fact, in some ways he was a victim), and is working to clean up the office. By doing what’s right, Republicans have turned the Swallow mess into a non-issue.
During the Great Winter Inversion of 2013-14, Wasatch Front residents of every political stripe expressed rage over dirty air. The Legislature passed a number of air quality bills, but many observers believe the effort was nominal. While some voters remain concerned, why is air quality a non-issue so far in election races?
Pignanelli: There are no elections during the inversion season. Any hacking and coughing plaguing Utahns between March and December is from mold and pollen. The rule “out of sight, out of mind” governs and few voters are bugging candidates about the issue.
Webb: Spring has sprung and the air is sweet and clean. It’s hard to stay upset about an aggravation that occurs just a few weeks of the year. Personally, I’d like to see air quality remain a high-profile issue. I’d like to see Republican and Democratic candidates explain how they will make a difference. Much can still be done, especially allowing local governments and local voters to decide if they want to expand public transit. (I worked with the Salt Lake Chamber’s Transportation Coalition on that issue.) Democrats should have a natural advantage on this issue, but clean air shouldn’t be a partisan matter. Both Republicans and Democrats have worked on air quality, so it’s hard for one party to gain advantage over another. Republican Rep. Johnny Anderson, for example, was the chief champion of expanding public transit.
- 33 Mark Twain quotes that prove he was an...
- Charles Krauthammer: The nation expects...
- John Florez: Audit reveals politicians'...
- Richard Davis: Can a Mormon not be a liberal?
- My view: Deeper look at Utah’s...
- Dan Liljenquist: Rights vs. privileges...
- A. Scott Anderson: Give students skills that...
- In our opinion: 'Lost Boy of Sudan' shows how...
- Richard Davis: Can a Mormon not be a... 76
- Jay Evensen: We're becoming a nation... 43
- Dan Liljenquist: Rights vs. privileges... 37
- Letter: Lessons for Greg Bell 30
- My view: The best legislation meets all... 30
- Letter: Legal weapons on campus 30
- Letter: Give her time 26
- My view: Congress must tackle tough issues 24