Utah High School Activities Association committee will examine impact of socio-economics on high school sports
SANDY — Matt Rickards watched the Kearns High soccer coach coaxing students to play for the school’s team and realized he had to do more than complain about a process he felt ignored the realities of prep competition.
“One of our coaches was walking down the hall and literally asking girls to come play because they needed to fill the team,” said the school’s head football coach. “At the time, we were competing in 5A, in a region with Bingham, Copper Hills, Riverton, and I thought, ‘How is it possible for us to even compete?’ ”
Rickards decided to investigate an assumption than many educators have theorized about for years — schools with more affluent populations have more success in extracurricular activities.
“One of my frustrations is that people know that socio-economic status should be considered across the state, but everybody had a defeatist mentality,” he said. Those he spoke with assumed that officials making the decisions understand the issues and simply choose to ignore them.
But the Utah High School Activities Association’s Board of Trustees listened to Rickard’s presentation on how poverty impacts win/loss ratios at Utah schools, as well as a presentation from the Ogden School District, and decided to reconvene the realignment committee to examine those issues in detail to see if they are being appropriately considered in region and classification assignments.
The board could have just approved the alignment the committee recommended in January, but some felt Wednesday night’s proposals were worth investigating.
While Region 3 representative Kim Horiuchi made the motion that eventually passed with a few 1A and 2A schools opposed, Norm Allred, Region 18’s representative, said he’d like to know for sure if there is any validity to the assertion that money matters.
“This way you’re addressing concerns that were raised at a public hearing,” said Tamara Lowe, who represents the Davis District.
What Rickards did was offer the board proof that schools with higher socio-economic status enjoy higher win/loss ratios. Those situations are exacerbated by the state’s open enrollment law, which allows students to attend any school that has room for them. They’re not allowed to transfer for athletic reasons, but most acknowledge this happens despite the UHSAA’s best efforts to stop or prevent it.
“With open enrollment, I’ve had many conversations with parents wanting to take their kids to and send them to Bingham because they feel like there are more opportunities because there is more money,” Rickards said. “It’s set up so the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. When parents feel like they have a student athlete who has any chance to play at the next level, they want to send them somewhere else.”
Rickards started by collecting data — student population, win/loss records, top 10 finishes and percentage of a school’s student body on free or reduced lunches. The last item is important because not only is it an indicator of a school population’s poverty rate, but students on free or reduced lunch are entitled to have their participation fees waived by a school. That means a school has less money to organize the same activities offered by schools where most of the students are paying fees, as well as participating in fundraisers and organizing booster clubs.
“This is not just an assumption on my part,” Rickards said. “The numbers are valid.”
Not only did the win-loss records show that more-affluent schools had higher winning records in all sports, he cited studies that confirm students from lower socio-economic situations struggle in the classroom.
- BYU basketball: Collinsworth sets NCAA career...
- BYU reaches 9-win plateau, hoping for bowl...
- Utah's first family of rodeo: Riding buckin'...
- College Football: Utah moves back into top...
- Morning links: Examining Utah's bowl...
- Utah Jazz excited for a crack at undefeated...
- Dick Harmon: After tossing 4 TDs, BYU's...
- BYU basketball analysis: How the Cougars...
- Utes outlast Colorado to cap best... 103
- College Football: Utah moves back into... 56
- BYU's big plays, big second half, spell... 43
- BYU basketball: Collinsworth sets NCAA... 35
- BYU holds on for tougher-than-expected... 34
- Dick Harmon: After tossing 4 TDs, BYU's... 33
- Utah State denies David Collette's... 30
- Morning links: Examining Utah's bowl... 28