Frank Pignanelli & LaVarr Webb: Is tearing down the prison and relocating worth the cost?

Published: Sunday, Jan. 12 2014 12:00 a.m. MST

The Utah State Prison and surrounding area in Salt Lake County Friday, March 8, 2013.

Jeffrey D. Allred, Deseret News

Enlarge photo»

The new year is starting off with plenty of hot issues to keep our politicians busy. Here are a few items that deserve a full measure of our wit and wisdom (such as it is).

The initiative to tear down the state prison in Draper and build a new one elsewhere is advancing slowly, but starting to gain momentum. Is a new prison worth the cost?

Pignanelli: “There is no more independence in politics than there is in jail.” — Will Rogers

Standing in the Capitol Rotunda, one can swing a sock filled with coins and will likely hit a lobbyist who represents a client interested in the prison relocation (including yours truly). There is a quiet but intense focus by many business and community organizations towards this issue.

In 1951, the state correctional facility was built in the quiet farmlands of southeastern Salt Lake County with the hope that many prisoners would learn agricultural trades. Over half a century of population expansion later, the prison is now in bustling Draper and smack middle of Utah's I-15 high tech corridor. Local developers make a legitimate case that bio-med and technology operations on the Draper site would foster thousands of jobs while providing the $500 million needed for a new modern prison.

That’s a neat trick. But most Utahns are suspicious this is just a real estate play to benefit only a handful of people. Their concerns are justified because political and business leaders have yet to publicly articulate — in an aggressive manner — a vision for the property. Gov. Gary Herbert and the Legislature are appropriately deliberate and transparent in the process, but they need to push forward to take advantage of lower bonding and construction costs. The facts and numbers are compelling the conclusion that high-technology companies, entrepreneurial startups, prisoners in need of better rehabilitation programs and — most important — taxpayers will benefit.

Webb: Moving the prison in the next several years is inevitable. It makes no sense to have a state prison in the middle of a major technology and business corridor where great demand exists for commercial and housing development. In addition, the current prison is very old, badly in need of major updating. We need a new, state-of-the-art prison that will be more secure, better for inmates, save administrative costs, and serve Utah’s needs for the next several decades. Obviously, this needs to be done right with no political influence from lobbyists and political insiders. The process requires complete transparency and proper oversight.

Lots of people on the left and right are worried about National Security Agency spying. Should we be concerned, or is this just “black helicopter” nonsense?

Pignanelli: In this environment of intense partisan sniping, when liberal Democrats and conservative Republicans agree on something — that the NSA has gone too far — then you know a bogeyman does exist. The people at this agency are patriots who wish to protect fellow Americans, but they have lost their way. Citizens are entitled to a right to privacy that is not jeopardized by over-expansive warrants and needless storage of their records. The NSA must be contained.

Try out the new DeseretNews.com design!
try beta learn more
Get The Deseret News Everywhere