Nearly 120 years ago, the federal government required marriage discrimination in the proposed Utah state constitution as a condition to becoming a state.
For 40 years the federal government had persecuted the people of Utah territory, including jailing polygamists, banning them from voting and holding public office, and preventing them from serving on juries. And over the years, many challenges to the constitutionality of this discrimination were heard and rejected by the federal courts.
In more recent years, the question of same-sex marriage arose. Utah joined other states in banning same-sex marriage by amending their state constitution. This was an extension of, and perfectly in harmony with, the discrimination that the federal government required for Utah's statehood, discrimination that has been repeatedly upheld in court battles over more than a century.
Now a federal judge has determined that this latest discrimination violates the U.S. Constitution. The appeals will ultimately lead to the U.S. Supreme Court making a final decision. And if the ruling is upheld, will the polygamists in Utah and other states then have the precedent they require to reverse 120 years of marriage discrimination against them? I should think so.
I wonder how many in the LGBT community and those who support them will, in turn, support the polygamists in their fight for marriage equality.
- In our opinion: Marriage definition on...
- About Utah: Big-time golf in little ol'...
- Peter Corroon: Generalizations about liberals...
- Drew Clark: Can the Supreme Court find...
- Frank Pignanelli & LaVarr Webb: We can't help...
- A. Scott Anderson: Overregulation hurts bank...
- Letter: No oversight at all
- Letter: Climate change is unjustified rhetoric
- In our opinion: Marriage definition on... 93
- Richard Davis: A historic moment for... 60
- Jay Evensen: U.S. silence troubling... 59
- Letter: Climate change is unjustified... 42
- Peter Corroon: Generalizations about... 37
- Letter: We can do better 27
- A. Scott Anderson: Overregulation hurts... 26
- In our opinion: Recent drowning of 800... 22