Judge declines to issue stay in same-sex marriage ruling
Governor, state attorneys say decision leaves Utah in 'chaos'
But it might be hard for the appeals court to overturn Shelby's decision because once people are married, it would be difficult to go back and undo those marriages, said Cassell, a former federal judge.
"The way this has played out is a little bit unusual in that now the state is trying to put the genie back into the bottle and that's always a little tricky to do," he said.
Shelby noted that the state didn't file a motion for a stay before he issued his ruling last Friday and didn't seek one until two or three hours afterward.
Lott said the judge's ruling on the Friday before Christmas "frankly surprised" the state. He said he thought that Shelby didn't intend to rule until early January, but "I personally believe it wouldn't have made much difference."
Lott argued that Shelby's order overrides the democratic voice of Utahns who voted in 2004 to define marriage as between one man and one woman. He asked Shelby to maintain the status quo.
But Shelby questioned what the status quo is at this point.
Tomsic argued that the status quo changed with Shelby's order and county clerks are obligated to issue marriage licenses to gay and lesbian couples.
"It is the law in Utah," she said.
In addition to seeking a stay from the 10th Circuit, the state also appealed Shelby's ruling on the lawsuit. Cassell said it would decide the outcome of the case, unless the U.S. Supreme Court steps in.
"But the Supreme Court reviews only a handful of cases every year, so statistically the odds are the 10th Circuit is going to have the final word on this one," he said.
Some counties in Utah declined to issue licenses based on a section of state code that makes it a class A misdemeanor for county clerks to give one to anybody but a man and a woman, Salt Lake County deputy district attorney Darcy Goddard told Shelby during the hearing.
Shelby said his ruling didn't identify every state law pertaining to marriage, but its intent was to not prohibit couples from exercising their constitutional right to marry.
Acting Utah Attorney General Brian Tarbet said after the hearing that county clerks should listen to what their county attorneys tell them.
"That's what the governor asked them to do in his letter of Saturday, is consult with your legal advisers. Those are their elected county attorneys," he said.
Nine of the state's 29 counties chose not to issue marriage licenses on Monday.
Tomsic said Gov. Gary Herbert's letter implies that counties shouldn't follow Shelby's order. She said that's no different than Gov. George Wallace not allowing a black girl in school, referring to the landmark Brown vs. Board of Education case in 1954 that overturned state-sponsored segregation.
Herbert, who called Shelby an "activist" judge last week, said he was not surprised at the court's refusal to grant a stay but was disappointed because of what he says are the ensuing results.
"The uncertainty is creating a lot of chaos. A stay would have been appropriate until we have a resolution," he said.
Herbert spoke just after he appointed Sean Reyes as Utah's new attorney general, replacing John Swallow who resigned this month. Tarbet has served as attorney general the past few weeks.
Reyes rejected the notion that the state's filing was not timely enough. He noted that the attorney general's office filed the motion soon after Shelby's ruling came down on Friday afternoon.
"I am not sure how much more prompt this office could have been," he said.
Herbert later issued a statement saying he's committed to advancing the issue through the courts as "we work toward a clear and understandable resolution."
“I recognize that this is a highly emotional issue with people of goodwill on both sides of the debate," he said. "I encourage everyone to remain respectful of one another and of the legal process.”
Shelby's Friday decision is the first in the country to address whether a state may ban same-sex marriage under the Constitution since the U.S. Supreme Court voided the section of the Defense of Marriage Act that defines marriage as between a man and a woman for purposes of federal law.
Gay couple Derek Kitchen and Moudi Sbeity and lesbian couple Laurie Wood and Kody Partridge filed a lawsuit challenging the law in March after Salt Lake County denied them marriage licenses. Karen Archer and Kate Call, who were legally married in Iowa, joined the suit because Utah does not recognize their marriage as valid.
Salt Lake County alone issued 124 marriage licenses to gay and lesbian couples within hours of Shelby's ruling on Friday and another 353 on Monday, according to the county clerk's office. It is unknown how many got married.
A Utah Policy/KSL poll of political insiders found 92 percent of Democrats and a surprising 53 percent of Republicans believe the 10th Circuit will uphold Shelby’s ruling on appeal.
Twitter: DNewsPolitics; dennisromboy
- Living on the edge: North Salt Lake residents...
- One man dead after attempted carjacking in Orem
- Body in suitcase is not missing Provo woman,...
- Historic Salt Lake building now home to...
- LDS artist J. Kirk Richards says leaps of...
- Wedding put on hold after BYU student kicked...
- Man dies in paragliding crash on Utah Lake
- Jury convicts San Juan County commissioner...
- Opposing sides of same-sex marriage... 124
- Outcome of same-sex marriage case hard... 54
- Stewart, Bishop launch group to take... 37
- Herbert, legislative leaders starting... 29
- Mitt Romney tells UVU grads to 'live a... 22
- 2 Utah chiefs with Baltimore ties say... 19
- Provo businessman declines push to run... 19
- LDS Church donates $100,000 to combat... 19