Waste plant and North Salt Lake neighborhood remain in conflict; residents want Stericycle plant shuttered
Jeffrey D. Allred, Deseret News
SALT LAKE CITY — Utah air quality regulators on Thursday revamped their case against the West's only medical waste incineration plant, modifying the allegations to reflect higher penalties.
It's the latest move in an ongoing dispute between Stericycle and North Salt Lake neighborhood residents who are pushing to shut down the incinerator and clean up the air.
"We want to keep pressure on the state to do something," said Natasha Hincks-Henderson, who is among the neighboring residents in the North Salt Lake Foxboro subdivision who said they are frustrated by the plant. She said the ultimate goal is to get Stericycle to use another method to dispose of medical waste.
Stericycle received a revised notice of violation that more accurately reflects the days the plant was violating the emission limits of its permit. The notice begins a new time frame for the company to respond to what the state describes as serIous violations of its permit.
Community meetings and protests have been staged this summer against Stericycle, ramping up after state regulators alleged in May the company was in violation of its permit at its North Salt Lake plant and had also falsified records.
Although several groups have called on state regulators and Gov. Gary Herbert to shut down the incinerator, such action isn't likely any time soon.
Bryce Bird, director of the Utah Division of Air Quality Control, said the permit can not be revoked until after the appeal process, which could take years.
"The most productive use of our time is getting additional emission controls in place as quickly as possible," Bird said. "It is not in their best interest or our best interest to start a legal fight."
The plant has been in compliance with its permit since June and has been subject to routine monitoring, Bird said.
"There are not any outstanding issues where they are still violating our rules."
In May, the division issued a notice of violation to the company, asserting it had violated emission limits established by its permit with the state and also falsified those records to demonstrate lower emission levels.
Regulators became suspicious in late 2011 and through 2012 during a series of three stack tests to determine the level and nature of pollutants released into the air from the plant. Tests are supposed to be conducted at the maximum production or combustion rate and reflect normal, operational variances, Bird said.
According to the notice of violation, Stericycle at first attempted to blame tests that were in violation of its emission limits on a flawed laboratory analysis. After the division obtained additional information, it found that a Dec. 27-28, 2011, test exceeded levels for hazardous pollutants, as well as nitrogen oxides, or highly reactive gases.
Bird said there were repeated problems with other tests and discrepancies that popped up in the company's logs that misled regulators, adding that information was manipulated that was not reflective of normal operating conditions.
That aspect of the air pollution case has been turned over to the Environmental Protection Agency and the Department of Justice for a criminal investigation, Bird said.
The state Division of Air Quality twice extended a deadline to come to a settlement — in which the company agrees to pay civil penalties and take additional steps to reduce its emissions.
Bird said the fine could be significant because it is a case the division takes seriously.
"Our intent is to hold them accountable," Bird said. "We're looking at additional controls and what else can be done to ultimately improve the situation for residents there."
- Officer in parade controversy speaks out on...
- RSL owner pulls offer to build new soccer...
- Gov. Herbert increases pressure on House to...
- Prophets and presidents: 11 noteworthy...
- Philanthropist forges ties with school...
- Uintah River High claims state basketball...
- Lawmakers to hear bill that would expand...
- Utah Supreme Court upholds...
- Officer in parade controversy speaks... 246
- Gov. Herbert: 'Let chips go where they... 70
- Should Utah have a partisan State... 36
- Officer was justified in shooting man... 35
- Gov. Herbert increases pressure on... 33
- Illinois professor could help Utah... 31
- House Speaker Greg Hughes kills hopes... 30
- House panel approves bill to require... 26