Doug Robinson: It's a new season, but the Utes' challenge remains the same

Published: Sunday, Aug. 25 2013 3:55 p.m. MDT

Co-offensive coordinator Dennis Erickson yells instructions during University of Utah football practice in Salt Lake City, Monday, Aug. 5, 2013.

Ravell Call, Deseret News

Another season, another offensive coordinator, another change to the offense — yep, must be the University of Utah football team. The Utes, who open the season Thursday night against Utah State, spent another off-season trying to fix their chronically gimpy offense, as usual.

Head coach Kyle Whittingham, a former all-conference linebacker and defensive coordinator, the son of an NFL linebacker and NFL/collegiate defensive coordinator, the brother of another all-conference linebacker, has defense in his blood. He’s spent his professional career trying to stop offenses; now he must find a way to make an offense go, or rather find someone who can do it for him. So far, that hasn’t panned out.

The Utes have struggled on offense and has lagged behind the defense for the most part (see accompanying chart). They ranked 109th and 105h in total offense the last two seasons, respectively, and haven’t cracked the top 40 since their unbeaten Sugar Bowl season in 2008.

“Each year brings new challenges, a new set of circumstances,” says Whittingham.

Or the same ones.

The offensive slide seems to have begun with the departure of offensive coordinator Andy Ludwig and the graduation of quarterback Brian Johnson in the 2008 season. Whittingham has tried just about everything to fix it — namely, six offensive coordinators in eight years, or five in the last five. Last season he hired the youngest offensive coordinator in the country, the 24-year-old Johnson. This season he has hired one of the oldest, pulling 66-year-old Dennis Erickson out of retirement.

It is the second time Whittingham has sought outside help. In 2011, he hired Norm Chow, a former national Assistant Coach of the Year who was once considered the hottest coaching commodity in the country. The Utes ranked 109th in total offense in one season under Chow, and then he left to accept a head coaching job at Hawaii (for what it’s worth, in the last five seasons, Chow’s teams — UCLA, Utah, Hawaii — have ranked 111th, 88th, 100th, 109th and 118th in total offense, respectively).

So now comes Erickson, a pleasant, relaxed man who has held 16 different coaching jobs since 1969, including head coaching positions at Idaho, Wyoming, Washington State, Miami (where he won two national championships), the Seattle Seahawks, Oregon State, the San Francisco 49ers, Idaho again and Arizona State.

Twice in the last decade Erickson has spent a year out of coaching only to return to the sideline. Fired by Arizona State at the end of the 2011 season, he helped coach his son’s high school team in Oregon occasionally.

After Utah’s continued offensive struggles last season, Whittingham found himself with another coaching vacancy when defensive line coach Chad Kauha’aha’a left for Wisconsin. He decided he could fill the vacancy with another offensive coordinator, but only if he was an exceptional coach.

“If no one stood out, I’d hire a defensive coach,” he says. He contacted Erickson in December.

“I had gotten to know him,” says Whittingham, “and I respected and admired him. My father thought a lot of him, too. That was part of it. He used to say, ‘That guy knows what he’s doing.’”

For his part, Erickson says, “I wasn’t sure I wanted to get back in it. I just got through a year without coaching. I was trying to do TV stuff and that didn’t work out. But I knew I missed football. I’m 66, and I thought if I’m going to get back in it, it better be now.”

It must have been a delicate issue to sell the idea to Johnson, a promising young coach in whom Whittingham publicly and privately expresses great confidence.

Try out the new DeseretNews.com design!
try beta learn more
Get The Deseret News Everywhere