Making a killing or getting fleeced? Differing accounting models muddy student loan debate
Pablo Martinez Monsivais, Associated Press
In a rare Washington compromise last week, Congress passed and President Obama signed a bill that temporarily lowered interest rates for student loan borrowers.
The rate each new borrower will get will change each year, sliding up and down based on U.S. Treasury bond prices. If the economy picks up, rates will climb.
The relief was welcomed by all sides, but some continue to argue rates should go even lower because the federal government now administers them. The debate is muddied by two dramatically different estimates from the same reliable source.
Using one model, the government will make $184 billion on education loans in the next 10 years. Using another, it will lose $95 billion.
It's a $279 billion accounting dispute. They can't both be right, and the dispute has enormous implications not just for student loans but for all kinds of federal loan programs, including home loans. One side cites enormous profits, the other enormous losses. Those stuck in the middle have few tools to navigate the divide.
“Instead of helping our students, the government is making a profit on student loans,” Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., said in July. “That is wrong. It is morally wrong. That is obscene.”
Warren sponsored an amendment, rejected by the Senate, that would have lowered the cap for undergraduate loans to 6.8 percent. Not everyone agrees with Warren that the government is making a killing on student loans. Some very serious voices are arguing that taxpayers actually are getting fleeced.
Warren has a point. The Congressional Budget Office estimated in June that under existing law the federal government would have raked in a $184 billion profit from student loans over the next 10 years. The figure was widely circulated in the student loan debate.
Since the CBO has long been widely recognized as the most objective and competent number cruncher around, Warren's use of its numbers should hardly be controversial.
But the CBO report also offered another number that got less attention — a $95 billion loss. That's what CBO projects using an alternate standard known as "fair-value accounting." Unlike standard government accounting, FVA factors market risk as private investors would, with the same perspective on risk.
On the same page and in the same table that the CBO says the government would likely earn $184 billion profit it also says that the government may instead lose $95 billion on the same loans over the same time period.
When Warren cited CBO numbers to bolster her claim that rates should come down, Glenn Kessler, the Fact Checker at the Washington Post, called her out. He awarded Warren two Pinocchios because she failed to mention that the CBO itself paired her more optimistic numbers with totally different fair-value estimates.
As Kessler noted, it is quite clear that the CBO favors the more skeptical model, but he still hesitated to make the call, indicating he did not really feel qualified to referee the competing accounting standards. His two Pinocchios out of four seemed almost a gesture of futility, arms thrown in the air, splitting the difference for lack of real clarity.
"We obviously are not going to take a position on the correct accounting method," Kessler wrote, adding that "ordinarily a CBO projection is worth its weight in gold. But this is an unusual situation. The respected and nonpartisan budget agency clearly has concerns about the method mandated by Congress — and the differences over the next 11 years are stunning."
The CBO position
- Utah taxpayers will pay millions more in wake...
- The top 10 dream colleges in 2015
- Test anxiety: How cold feet are ruining your...
- BYU student claims he was evicted after...
- Young entrepreneurs strut their stuff in bid...
- School for kids with autism helps inside and...
- Colleges getting out of health insurance...
- Photos: Students 'duck' tape principal to...
- BYU student claims he was evicted after... 50
- Utah taxpayers will pay millions more... 35
- Q & A: What UNC's cheating scandal can... 5
- Colleges getting out of health... 2
- Teen chefs compete in state cooking... 2
- This week in history: Madrid falls to... 1
- Revenge of the nerds: How STEM fest... 1
- Group holding education summit 1