Prosecutors can proceed in murder case against Martin MacNeill, judge rules
Al Hartmann, 2012
PROVO — A judge on Monday declined to disqualify the Utah County Attorney's Office from prosecuting the case of a Pleasant Grove doctor charged with killing his wife.
The judge ruled that any issues had either been resolved or had not prejudiced the case.
"The motion to disqualify the (Utah) County Attorney's Office is denied," 4th Distrist Judge Samuel McVey ruled in the case of Martin MacNeill Monday. "We can proceed on this case."
MacNeill, 57, is charged with murder, a first-degree felony, and obstruction of justice, a second-degree felony, in the April 11, 2007, death of his wife, Michele MacNeill, 50. His defense attorneys had filed a motion asking to disqualify the Utah County Attorney's Office from the case, alleging that prosecutors failed to provide requested information in a timely manner that may have helped their client.
The defense also alleged that investigators tried to interview MacNeill despite knowing that he had an attorney in a fraud case, disclosed information about the case to the media, and didn't comply with requests for evidence and information, including emails.
"The remedy is to not disqualify the state, but make them produce the evidence, and that is what has been done," the judge said. He also said investigators were allowed to speak to the media in an effort to further their case and that their attempt to interview MacNeill didn't cause any problems since MacNeill didn't actually speak with them.
MacNeill's trial will begin as scheduled in October.
Prosecutors allege that MacNeill overmedicated his wife, administered a dangerous combination of drugs and drowned her in the bathtub of their home. MacNeill had worked as a doctor and had a law degree, both of which police believe he used "to commit the murder and frustrate the investigation in an attempt to cover it up," court documents state.
Soon after his wife's death, MacNeill's longtime mistress, Gypsy Willis, moved into the MacNeill house as the children's new nanny. Prosecutors contend MacNeill killed his wife to be with Willis.
MacNeill's defense attorneys, however, have long countered that Michele MacNeill's death was an accident.
Monday's hearing also addressed whether the judge will allow testimony from Willis' former roommates. Defense attorney Randall Spencer argued their comments about Willis' prior "bad acts" — including an interest in a TV show about undetectable drugs — are irrelevant because they predate Willis' relationship with MacNeill and would lead to prejudice against MacNeill. He claimed the state was "seeking to muddy the water in a circumstantial case even more to try and get the jury to associate bad acts of Gypsy Willis with Martin MacNeill."
But prosecutor Sam Pead countered that the testimony was important in establishing motive.
"Gypsy Willis is the mistress, she is the motive," Pead said, adding Willis wanted to take Michele MacNeill's place. "These people were in bed together both figuratively and literally and we can infer that she had communications with him about this."
The judge said he wouldn't prohibit testimony from Willis' roommates at trial altogether, but that he would wait until after Willis testifies before determining what specific testimony to allow.
Email: firstname.lastname@example.org, Twitter: DNewsCrimeTeam
- Rep. Justin Miller pleads guilty to...
- Photo gallery: Night skies over national parks
- Pres. Nelson honored by the University of Utah
- Police seek alleged drug money from woman...
- Is 'Speaker Chaffetz' more likely with...
- Utah man impresses all four judges on 'The...
- Rep. Jason Chaffetz says he wouldn't run...
- Inmate charged with sending threatening...
- Is 'Speaker Chaffetz' more likely with... 68
- Chaffetz's run for speaker makes... 47
- Utah cites Warren Jeffs as reason... 42
- Scholars disagree whether compromise... 41
- Gov. Herbert says latest Medicaid... 29
- Proposal calls for 900 South to be... 20
- Judge dismisses negligence lawsuit... 15
- Lawmakers hear support for Medicaid... 15