Girls are getting better grades than boys, but is anyone getting a good education?
Have schools improved the way they educate girls, or have they just made it harder for boys to succeed?
Archive
A new study from the University of Georgia and Columbia University suggests girls get better grades than boys because of their classroom behavior. According to Psychcentral.com, girls in the study were rated higher on six measures: "the child’s attentiveness, task persistence, eagerness to learn, learning independence, flexibility and organization."
Less than two decades ago, researchers were working to help schools better address the needs of girls, who lagged behind, especially in math and science. Girls' quiet, "good" behavior led teachers to ignore them more often and call on them less frequently than their more rambunctious male peers.
One study from 1995 found that "girls receive fewer academic contacts, are asked lower level questions, and are provided less constructive feedback and encouragement than boys — all of which translates into reduced preparation for independent effort."
Now that girls are at the top of the class, questions remain about whether anyone is getting a good education in a school system that prioritizes sitting still, being quiet and taking tests over connection, collaboration, humor and spontaneity.
Gretchen Krebs has taught general and special education in New York and Utah. She is passionate about finding innovative approaches to meet the needs of all students. Contact her at gkrebs@deseretnews.com
- $2.6B needed for Utah to reach per-pupil...
- Education coalition attacks Utah's efforts to...
- Salt Lake Valley's healthiest principals earn...
- Experts stress the importance of teaching...
- University of Utah makes list of...
- Roosevelt teen on bike hits school bus
- One third of millenials regret going to college
- Obama threatens veto of Republican student...
- $2.6B needed for Utah to reach...
14 - Should we let wunderkinds drop out of...
13 - Education coalition attacks Utah's...
6 - Obama threatens veto of Republican...
5 - AIG CEO tells college graduates facing...
5 - Innovative schools share ideas to...
3 - One third of millenials regret going to...
3 - First lady Michelle Obama to high...
1



Are test scores related to better education?
Girls have always matured quicker then boys, but the problem, are the boys lack a male role model. Few have a dad, or men teachers.
Men are also put down on television, and movies. More..
I think for a boys school is hard. It is much more structured today. Plus the absence of male role models in elementary is especially hurting. Add in the addition of more single parent families run mostly by mothers and boys would logically feel More..