Quantcast

Utah pollution plan 'incomplete,' but new rules abound

Published: Wednesday, Dec. 5 2012 6:40 p.m. MST

Inversion over the Wasatch Front Sunday, Dec. 18, 2011 looking west from South Mounatin. Utah forged ahead with a pollution-reducing plan that includes the adoption of more than a dozen new rules for road work, automotive painting, printing and paving companies during a marathon board meeting Wednesday.

Scott G Winterton, Deseret News

SALT LAKE CITY — Utah forged ahead with a pollution-reducing plan that includes the adoption of more than a dozen new rules for road work, automotive painting, printing and paving companies during a marathon board meeting Wednesday that still leaves the toughest challenges for last.

While many of the new emission limits are designed to help Utah comply with mandates of the federal Clean Air Act for fine particulate pollution, limits on the big contributors — such as industry in the Provo and Salt Lake County areas — remain on the drafting board.

Dave McNeill, branch manager of the Division of Air Quality, said the Environmental Protection Agency and the state have agreed to a six-month delay in submitting the component of the plan that deals with what technological controls industry will have to install to cut the pollution.

"We would rather be late (and) right than to be wrong on time," McNeill said. "We will make (the deadline) by 2014, with the extension to go out through 2019."

Utah has some of the country's dirtiest air in its urban areas, fostered by mountainous terrain, the Great Salt Lake and a burgeoning population in love with its automobiles.

When high-pressure systems trap that pollution in the winter and ozone spikes in the summer heat, public health is compromised — not only for those with respiratory problems and the elderly and very young, but for anyone exposed for long periods.

Numerous studies have linked spiking pollution levels to increased incidences of stroke or cardiac events, and clean air advocates contend even the federal threshold set for pollution limits isn't protective enough for public health.

Utah air quality regulators have been crafting a pollution-reducing plan since the state landed on the list of being out of compliance in 2009, a laboriously technical and protracted effort that has involved dozens upon dozens of meetings with business owners and operators, the public and clean air advocates.

Their target, they concede, may be practically impossible to reach, but the federal dictate was staring them in the face with an adoption deadline of Dec. 14.

"The general theme is that it is incomplete, and we acknowledge that," said Bill Reiss, the state's point man for crafting the plan.

Reiss added that more analysis needs to be done on how much new technological controls will reduce pollution from big emitters and whether the bang is worth the bucks invested.

"Step one is identifying everything you can think of that will help you along the way, and step two is basically looking at the (sum) of that and testing that against the model of what you feel meets the criteria of being reasonable," he said. "It has to be both technically feasible and economically feasible."

Board member Kathy Van Dame, who is also with the Wasatch Clean Air Coalition, was blunt in her disappointment that controls on big industry still remain unfinished in the plan.

"It is seriously so disappointing to me that we keep hearing it is almost done, almost done," Van Dame said.

Reiss acknowledged that the plan is incomplete, saying the division simply ran out of time.

"Industry is very obviously a visible component, but this is not their first (plan)," he said. "I would not offer anybody that this is the silver bullet. … It is still going to be a tough road to get to attainment, and it is still going to take longer than 2014 to get there."

The Division of Air Quality is embracing a strategy that loops new polluters under the umbrella of regulatory controls while holding out hope that as cleaner-burning cars take to the roads in the next five years, tailpipe emissions will drastically decrease.

Get The Deseret News Everywhere

Subscribe

Mobile

RSS