Mormon Media Observer: George Romney showed problems with how press covers campaigns
In his assessment of the 1968 campaign, the great Theodore White wrote, "Most important ... was the gulf between the man and the national media, who could not understand each other — Romney’s billboards in New Hampshire read THE WAY TO STOP CRIME IS TO STOP MORAL DECAY; he could not understand why newsmen found the slogan funny; and they could not understand what he meant by moral decay."
The media, in short, gave short shrift to the campaign of George Romney.
I have long suspected that his son's reticence to talk about religion and certain aspects of his life and politics stems from studying his father's presidential campaign. Mitt seems to have learned that saying too much can cost you. So it's no small irony that despite his relative discipline, the press seems to portray Mitt Romney lately as it did his father, as bumbling, square and out-of-touch.
Be that as it may, however, all that isn't the primary lesson of the coverage of the presidential campaign of George Romney. What is the lesson is the one Teddy White found — the power the news media wields in shaping our perceptions of presidential candidates is extraordinary.
It wasn't always like that.
Before the 1960s, political parties wielded the greatest power in selecting political candidates, but with the rise of a new type of political reporting — one driven by narrative — and with the growth of primaries as the most important means of selecting candidates, the power of party functionaries declined, to be replaced by the press.
In what may be the most insightful book ever written on the topic, "Out of Order," Harvard scholar Thomas Patterson wrote that the press has, almost by default, inherited the job of vetting candidates and organizing the election process — mainly because the parties are no longer able to do it.
The press, however, is too diffuse for this role, and the results of the chaos have harmed our electoral system.
As one reviewer notes, with the press focus on the ebbs and flows of polls and on the strategies of candidates rather than on substantive issues, what the voters want increasingly differs from what the press delivers. Furthermore, with the focus on conflict among campaigns, media coverage actually increases overall cynicism in the electoral process among voters.
Some writers, such as Tim Crouse, have argued that 1968 marked the beginning of this new press-driven system, and the system's first victim, if you will, was George Romney.
Today, it is easy to find people complimenting the remarkable career of George Romney, a true public servant, even as some do it to dimish his son.
In that there's the rub: It's hard not to conclude that the press' relentless framing of a bumbling George Romney weeded out the wrong guy in 1968, because the man who beat Romney in the primary was Richard Nixon.
To be sure, Nixon had remarkable strengths and many people appreciate much of his legacy, but it is hard to imagine that George Romney would have needed to resign in disgrace for covering up a second-rate burglary. It makes one wonder how our nation would have been different had a cynic like Nixon not won in 1968.
Now, I am not saying either Barack Obama or Mitt Romney is another Nixon, but in this strange, frustrating election system we have now, we just don't know much about our candidates' true characters despite the relentless coverage, and it's more than possible that a few decades from now we'll look back and say we elected the wrong guy.
Lane Williams teaches journalism and communication at BYU-Idaho. He is a former journalist whose scholarly interests include Mormon portrayals in the media, media and religion, and religion and politics.
- What The New York Times gets wrong about...
- In our opinion: It's time for Utah to adopt a...
- My view: Now is the time for significant...
- Michael and Jenet Erickson: Utah businesses...
- Jay Evensen: Will Obama visit Utah? Do we care?
- Dan Liljenquist: Predictions for the 2015...
- W. Bradford Wilcox: Yes, women and children...
- In our opinion: Fairness for all in religious...
- What The New York Times gets wrong... 54
- Michael and Jenet Erickson: Utah... 49
- In our opinion: It's time to end the... 42
- Mike Lee: Tax reform shouldn't penalize... 38
- In our opinion: Fairness for all in... 37
- Jay Evensen: Will Obama visit Utah? Do... 37
- In our opinion: Disney outbreak sends a... 33
- Robert Bennett: Obama's State of the... 31