A new normal: Why broadcast shows are looking more like cable
For example, last year the “Game of Thrones” series premiere drew approximatley 2.2 million viewers and the season finale drew about 3.04 million sets of eyeballs. Those numbers were big enough to induce HBO to renew the series. However, for primetime programming on broadcast networks an audience of only 3 million viewers would likely result in immediate cancellation. Indeed, consider the fate of “The Playboy Club” — the show NBC cancelled in 2011 after its three episodes averaged “only” 4 million viewers per showing.
Second, industry experts note that the business models of premium cable and broadcast television are inherently different. Whereas HBO is purely in the business of selling subscriptions, broadcast networks must sell advertisements to survive. And, in fact, watchdog groups have successfully pressured advertisers to drop commercials during shows the groups deem objectionable.
“I think it’s important for us to have a good understanding of where we stand in our relationship with the networks,” Henson said. “I think most of us tend to assume wrongly that we are the audience that networks are programming for, and that if they’re putting this stuff out there it must mean there’s a demand for it. And I don’t think that’s necessarily true.
“We are actually the product, and the consumer that they’re trying to reach is the company that’s buying ad time. And they’re selling us as eyeballs that are going to see those ads.”
Perception becomes reality
The idea that broadcast programming increasingly emulates cable offerings carries with it the strong implication that cable shows are simply the better fare at this point in time. And that belief — putting aside the question of whether it's a valid presumption — is manifesting itself in myriad ways.
Consider, for example, this year's six contenders for the primetime Emmy for Outstanding Drama Series. For the first time ever, not a single nominee comes from one of the four major broadcast networks: HBO and AMC each produced two nominated series, while Showtime and PBS yielded one nominee apiece.
To that end, the New York Times' Mike Hale openly wondered last week whether critics are withholding praise from several excellent broadcast programs purely because the shows don't hail from a cable outlet.
"The real victims of cable envy — the notion that creativity and distinction in TV drama now lie entirely with cable channels like AMC, HBO and Showtime and their model of short seasons, serialized stories and writer-producer autonomy — are the shows that don’t get the credit they deserve because the attention of critics, and the TV industry itself, is so firmly focused elsewhere," Hale wrote.
It isn’t all bad news if network programming adopts certain characteristics of cable shows, some TV critics say. For example, new primetime series such as FOX’s comedy “The Mindy Project” and ABC’s drama “Nashville” are earning a consensus of rave reviews for sophistication and scope.
Common Sense Media TV editor Sierra Filucci noted that when objectionable content appears on broadcast television during primetime programming, parents who watch the shows together with their children can translate those moments into invaluable opportunities to casually dialogue with their teens.
"It’s certainly challenging for parents because there are so many more places for kids to consume media, and there’s so much more media out there," Filucci said. "It’s not just network television, and it’s not just one television in the living room that kids can watch. Kids are watching on their phones, on their computers, on cable
"(But) our No. 1 message is still to talk to kids and keep the lines of communication open, and as much as possible to watch alongside kids — especially primetime TV, which can be a great time for families to hang out in the living room and watch TV together. A lot of that content is not appropriate for younger kids and tweens, but it can be something that teenagers and their parents can watch together and then just talk about what happens."
J.G. Askar is a graduate of BYU's J. Reuben Clark Law School and member of the Utah State Bar. Contact him at email@example.com or 801-236-6051.
- Utah's One Voice Children's Choir to perform...
- How Maroon 5 helped me lose weight and...
- About Utah: She showed him the light
- LDS convert Danor Gerald is star of new...
- MAC Commissioner: ESPN deal brings stability
- Utah family shares quirky, inspiring Mormon...
- Millcreek to host car show, movie night
- Theater review: CenterPoint's whimsical...