Mormon Media Observer: Time to end the 'secrecy' allegation against Mormons
SALT LAKE CITY — Can we just stop with the secrecy stuff already?
One of the most common stereotypes I see in coverage of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is that we Latter-day Saints are secretive.
Dan Harris's two-part series about the church for ABC this week was dripping with that stereotype. The series led with the stereotype in his first installment and played it up in his second part. Furthermore, Brian Williams' disappointing "Rock Center" documentary included the same stereotype frequently.
In fairness to Harris and to NBC, I don't think the reporting constituted a deliberate hatchet job on the LDS Church. (Harry Smith's piece on LDS welfare certainly was no hatchet job.)
I think all the reporters were trying to be fair, but it's a shame to have the focus on secrecy. (NBC's decision to show LDS garments was especially troubling. I mean, really, a focus on underwear?)
To be sure, Harris, Williams and other reporters who have used this secrecy stereotype sometimes ask Latter-day Saints (or estranged Latter-day Saints) about this perception or stereotype, and those Saints sometimes choose to acknowledge things that outsiders see as secretive — and then those same Latter-day Saints try to explain the so-called secrecy in terms or persecution and hesitancy in entering the mainstream.
So, if a scholar or other Latter-day Saint concurs, even in slight ways, with the stereotype, it's hard for reporters to avoid the conclusion that Latter-day Saints are secretive.
But I differ with that conclusion, and strongly.
If we Latter-day Saints are so secretive, can someone explain to me why it is so many of us volunteer for two years to explain just about anything people might want to know about our faith — full time?
If we Latter-day Saints are so secretive, why do our leaders in Salt Lake City make an effort to share more about our beliefs through lds.org, mormon.org and the "I'm a Mormon" campaign? Why do we invite anyone and everyone to our church meetings? Why does the church's website include a vast library of hundreds of links about the church and its doctrine? Why the vast emphasis on general conference and getting it to as broad a public as possible? Why the remarkable translation services? I know of nothing equivalent anywhere in the world of religion.
No, we are not secretive. We love to share. Did you see the Latter-day Saints in the Rock Center documentary? They seemed hardly secretive to me.
I acknowledge that Latter-day Saints choose not to disclose specifics about individual members, about financial matters and about the temple. I acknowledge that the way the church presents itself depends on the audience.
But many organizations avoid disclosing finances, specifics about individuals and about their sacred spaces. It is fully consistent with Christianity to not disclose cherished beliefs with those who wouldn't appreciate them, who wouldn't or couldn't hold them sacred. And certainly, almost any organization will tailor its messages depending on the audience.
As I see it, there is nothing particularly unusual or sinister about any of the church's discretion.
The problem with presenting Latter-day Saints as secretive is three-fold: First, it perpetuates a stereotype that hearkens to the oldest of the anti-Mormon tomes: Eber Howe's "Mormonism Unvailed" (sic). Basically, reporters continue a trope that started with those kinds of often anti-Mormon books — that there is something sinister at the core of the Mormon faith.
Second, the stereotype may have political consequences. Now, I try to avoid mixing politics and religion, but I think many political consultants know that people assume Latter-day Saints are secretive — with the sinister undertone that word implies.
- LDS Church names Elder Clayton new senior...
- From tragedy to lives touched, Chris Williams...
- Sunday School leader apologizes for...
- Unique LDS temple, high-rise apartment...
- The spiritual revolution taking place away...
- 185th Semiannual General Conference talk...
- President Thomas S. Monson: 'Be an Example...
- Photos: LDS general conference Sunday morning...
- Elders Rasband, Stevenson, Renlund... 47
- Workers removing Ten Commandments from... 40
- Unique LDS temple, high-rise apartment... 37
- Sunday School leader apologizes for... 33
- Lois M. Collins: The 'death' of faith... 32
- The spiritual revolution taking place... 18
- In Saturday's General Conference... 16
- LDS Church leaders continue to... 16