Herbert, legislative leaders agree state can ban target shooting to prevent fires

Gov. calls the legal situation 'complicated'

Published: Monday, July 2 2012 8:32 p.m. MDT

At least one recent fire was believed to have been started by target shooters, but the so-called "Dump Fire" was apparently sparked within an incorporated area. In a press conference Monday, Gov. Gary Herbert said it is up to local governments to place any restrictions on target shooting within their limits.

Shutterstock

Enlarge photo»

Read more: Weather conditions ahead of holiday are 'recipe for disaster,' fire marshal says

Read more: Fire Watch: Full coverage of active Utah wildfires

Read more: Firework restrictions throughout Utah

SALT LAKE CITY — Gov. Gary Herbert said Monday the state forester has the power to ban target shooting in unincorporated areas of the state where fire danger is high and will work with local authorities to start putting restrictions in place.

The governor's announcement came after a 1½-hour, closed-door meeting with legislative leaders and a number of attorneys over whether a special session was needed to put a stop to target shooting in the wake of hundreds of fires.

Neither Senate President Michael Waddoups, R-Taylorsville, nor House Speaker Becky Lockhart, R-Provo, appeared to have any interest in changing the law to restrict target shooting, but both agreed it could be handled by state Forester Dick Buehler.

The governor had suggested earlier Monday he may well have the ability to ban fireworks and target shooting throughout the state, but said after the meeting with legislative leaders he didn't want to have that theory tested in court.

Herbert called the legal situation "complicated" at a hastily called 6 p.m. news conference.

"None of us were into a blanket, one-size-fits-all approach," the governor said. 

Lockhart agreed.

"We're not interested in blanket bans. We're not interested in any way in limiting people's 2nd Amendment right to carry firearms in their own interest," the speaker said. 

Waddoups said he had "total confidence" nobody's rights were being infringed upon by the decision.

"We're not trying to take away peoples' right to enjoy the holidays," he said, or their right to use firearms for self-defense or hunting.

The state forester has already implemented a ban on fireworks throughout the state in unincorporated areas. The areas where target shooting is banned, however, may be more limited.

Buehler said he would be "prudent" in issuing restrictions, even though the state "is experiencing the worst fire conditions in memory right now," already setting a record for the number of federal assistance grants for fighting blazes.

At least one recent fire was believed to have been started by target shooters, but the so-called "Dump Fire" was apparently sparked within an incorporated area. Herbert said it is up to local governments to place any restrictions on target shooting within their limits.

Earlier Monday, the governor told the Deseret News something needed to be done. He first broached the idea last week of calling a special legislative session to give local law enforcement the power to ban target shooting.

"Clearly, I think there's a need just for public safety purposes to either have the governor be able to do that, to declare an emergency situation, to maybe have a little more carte blanche ability to set parameters on firearms and fireworks," Herbert said. "If not, there's certainly the local control."

Waddoups had already questioned last week whether changing the law was needed and suggested the executive branch already had the necessary authority.

"It's campaign season," the senate president said when asked why a special session was being discussed.

He said some senators have already expressed concern that local law enforcement authorities could abuse the power to restrict gun use.

"As soon as you do it, somebody may carry it to extreme," Waddoups said.

Get The Deseret News Everywhere

Subscribe

Mobile

RSS