Make it a small: N.Y.'s ban on large sodas likely won't take in Utah

Published: Thursday, May 31 2012 6:00 p.m. MDT

Brandon Stephens walks from a convenience store to his home in Salt Lake City, Thursday, May 31, 2012 after buying a fountain drink.

Ravell Call, Deseret News

SALT LAKE CITY — Every morning, Ken Ekker fills his 100-ounce drink jug at a convenience store.

"I've been filling this thing up for a good five or six years now," the West Jordan construction worker said, adding that he'd rather not have to stop working to get a refill later in the day.

And while Ekker doesn't appear overweight, he's one of a growing number of Americans contributing to the overconsumption of soft drinks, an issue experts believe is making people fat.

Not only are people drinking more soda in general, but portion sizes have increased dramatically and the cost per ounce has plummeted, making it more accessible than ever before, said Patrice Isabella, a dietitian with the Utah Department of Health's Physical Activity, Nutrition and Obesity program.

Americans consumed 13.8 billion gallons of sugar-sweetened beverages in 2009, which is roughly 70,000 calories per person, according to a recent publication in the journal Health Affairs. The numbers are directly correlated with growing waistlines across the country, as the overweight and obese populations are higher than ever before.

"Soft drinks contribute significantly nationwide to the number of empty calories consumed by adults and children and it is aggressively marketed to children," Isabella said. "It's a problem because the body doesn't regulate very well when calories are consumed in liquid form, which puts us at a significant risk for obesity."

Obesity is at an all-time high in Utah, with more than 60 percent of the population carrying more weight than is ideal, according to the health department. That rate has more than doubled since 1989, but remains below the national average of about 63.1 percent of the population being overweight or obese.

State and national governments have tossed around various ideas to deal with America's obesity epidemic, specifically involving soft drinks. But Congress is now addressing legislation that may prohibit the use of federal funds to combat big advertising pushes by the food and beverage industry.

Private organizations have effected changes, such as better labels on beverages and more healthier options in schools, but until now, governments have laid low on the matter.

New York City officials this week announced an intention to impose a ban on the sale of soft drinks larger than 16 ounces at all restaurants, sports arenas, movie theaters and street carts. The action is intended to increase public health, but won't take effect until sometime next year.

"If we want something big, we should be able to buy something big, especially if we're willing to pay for it," said Salt Lake resident Tammy Jenkins. "I just don't feel like they have the right to make that choice for us. I understand the purpose, but I also agree with the fact that I'm an adult."

Isabella said such a move to restrict sales isn't likely in Utah, due to the "anti-regulatory political atmosphere here." But tactics including higher prices for more soda or imposing a tax on sweetened beverages are more feasible and could have an impact on the rising levels of soft drink consumption.

In 2011, Rep. Dixon Pitcher, R-Ogden, floated a bill that would impose a 1 percent tax on soft drinks purchased throughout Utah. The additional revenue would have helped fund education, but lawmakers agreed not to introduce it, as it would raise taxes in the thick of an economic recession.

The self-declared "water guy" only drinks soda or juice on occasion, and said he has been flooded with information about the harmful effects of soft drinks since he introduced the bill last year.

"When you super size that soda drink, it's surprising what that can do to you as far as adding on calories. There's so much sugar in carbonated drinks," Pitcher said.

Try out the new DeseretNews.com design!
try beta learn more
Get The Deseret News Everywhere