Controversial sex ed bill was designed to remove Planned Parenthood from schools

Published: Friday, March 16 2012 6:00 p.m. MDT

SALT LAKE CITY — Utah lawmakers say a controversial sex education bill was designed to end collaboration between the State Office of Education and Planned Parenthood.

But representatives from both organizations say collaboration ceased last year.

After weeks of heated debate, rallies and petitions, the fight for sex education in Utah continues as opponents and supporters of HB363 await the decision of Gov. Gary Herbert. The bill — which bans instruction on contraceptives, intercourse and homosexuality — has drawn the full gamut of responses, from parents who stress that discussions on sexual activity belong solely in the home to others who worry the bill would keep potentially life-saving information from students who may not receive it otherwise.

Herbert is expected to decide on the bill next week and his spokeswoman said Friday that the governor is thoughtfully deliberating HB363 and will announce his decision when he makes it.

Rep. Bill Wright, R-Holden, sponsored the bill and has said that in addition to reasserting the role of parents in the education of their children, he was motivated by what he perceived as inappropriate material being presented in schools. Specifically, he mentioned material developed by Planned Parenthood and links on the Utah State Office of Education website that directed users to Planned Parenthood content.

Wright could not be reached for comment Friday but said after the bill cleared the Legislature that HB363 would "help us set a path in the future where our curriculum doesn't get hijacked."

Sen. Margaret Dayton, the bill's Senate sponsor, said Wright had tried for years to have the website links taken down. But it was not until HB363 favorably passed the House Education Committee that the two organizations were "decoupled."

"It was the links between the State Office of Education and Planned Parenthood that urged (Wright), in reality, to tighten up the abstinence-only teaching," Dayton, R-Orem, said.

But Karrie Galloway, CEO of Planned Parenthood Association of Utah, said those links were removed nearly one year ago. They were removed after a Bountiful parent complained about the content of a maturation presentation produced by Planned Parenthood called "Growing Up Comes First" and the apparent endorsement of that program on the office of education's website.

After the bill cleared the Legislature, Galloway said there was talk that a lingering image of the education board's logo may have inadvertently remained somewhere in their system. But she said their website and materials had since been searched "with a fine-toothed comb" to remove any and all references to the office of education.

"When the whole fracas happened last spring, we thought we had removed every recommendation by the State Office of Education," Galloway said.

Galloway said "Growing Up Comes First" is used by a number of school districts in their fifth- and sixth-grade maturation programs and for years, Planned Parenthood worked with the board of education to make the program available to schools. Galloway said there is nothing objectionable in the material and added that districts were free to incorporate or abandon portions of "Growing Up Comes First" as they deemed fit for their students.

"I find it to be a very well-respected curriculum and it is sensitive to local communities," she said.

The program focuses on the developmental changes that accompany puberty, she said, and educates students on topics like acne and body hair and gender-specific subjects like menstrual cycles and erections. Typically, schools separate students by gender and present only the information relevant to each group.

Try out the new DeseretNews.com design!
try beta learn more
Get The Deseret News Everywhere