Adela Valdez says the Pledge of Allegiance in Mrs. Helen Bingham's 2nd and 3rd grade joint class at the Woodrow Wilson School in Salt Lake City on Friday, Aug. 5, 2011.
Kristin Murphy, Deseret News
SALT LAKE CITY — The Utah Senate gave preliminary approval Monday to a bill that would require all Utah public school students to recite the Pledge of Allegiance each school day.
SB223, sponsored by Sen. Aaron Osmond, R-South Jordan, passed 26-0 on the bill's second reading.
Osmond said his hope is to restore students' respect for the flag and country.
"I feel like we need to get back to basics."
The pledge is now recited in public elementary schools but Osmond has observed
apathy toward the practice.
"As I went from school to school, there was very little, if any engagement, especially in Title I schools," he said.
Although she voted for the bill, Sen. Luz Robles, D-Salt Lake, remarked that students should be reminded of how they gained their freedoms. "The lack of engagement, I think, happens equally in Title I schools as other schools," she said.
Other senators said the bill raises some concerns because there needs to be consideration of people who do participate in the pledge due to religious or personal reasons.
Sen. Ross Romero, D-Salt Lake, said making the pledge compulsory in junior and senior high schools may "lessen respect and dedication to the pledge."
"If the public is going to want us to support this, I want to hear from them."
E-mail: marjorie@desnews.com
- Utah facing $1.2 billion-dollar water...
- Utah GOP convention agenda includes vote on...
- Democrats call for legislative hearings into...
- NTSB says dropping legal limit for...
- Health care reform about to 'get real' for...
- Feds fight Utah over measure to curb law...
- Utah lawmakers look to regulate child access...
- New law banning teen drivers from cellphones...
- Utah GOP convention agenda includes...
20 - Swallow headlines spark question:...
12 - Utah facing $1.2 billion-dollar water...
10 - Health care reform about to 'get real'...
7 - Democrats call for legislative hearings...
5 - Utah lawmakers look to regulate child...
4 - Valentine: Too soon to say whether...
1 - School officials report on class size...
1



I am not so sure that reciting the pledge will increase student appreciation for the American system. But I am sure that good, honest discussions of both the good and bad moments of the American story can foster student interest in the American More..
This ironically symbolic effort on the part of Utah politicians is bound fail and be stayed and overturned in the Federal Courts once again with more precious state taxpayer dollars wasted on an inevitable lawsuit that has already been to the U.S. More..
Even a good idea can be seen as a bad one. While I agree with the pledge being important, requiring it by law removes freedom that is promised by the Government. Ironically, this bill probably is unconstitutional.