Debate over Redskins name more intense that ever

By Joseph White

Associated Press

Published: Sunday, Aug. 10 2014 12:00 a.m. MDT

In this Aug. 3, 2010, file photo, Washington Redskins owner Dan Snyder attends a workout at the NFL football team's training camp in Ashburn, Va. The campaign to ditch "Redskins" by those who consider it a racial slur has reached unprecedented momentum over the last 18 months. Snyder has always vowed never to change the name.

Carolyn Kaster, File, Associated Press

Enlarge photo»

WASHINGTON — Mark Moseley has been associated with the Washington Redskins for some four decades as a league MVP kicker, member of a Super Bowl-winning team and general ambassador in his work with the franchise's alumni association. He's seen the debate over the team's nickname come and go since the 1970s, usually as a flash-in-the-pan topic that disappears after a day or so.

This time is different. The campaign to ditch "Redskins" by those who consider it a racial slur has reached unprecedented momentum over the last 18 months. "We all thought it would just go away," Moseley said. "Because it is such a ridiculous subject."

Moseley concedes that the debate shows no signs of abating, and he's recently become more active in supporting team owner Dan Snyder's quest to keep the name. Both sides are digging in, the words are getting nastier, and there's no real possibility of compromise: Either the name stays or it goes.

Theories abound as to why Snyder is on the defensive like never before.

"Politicians," said Joe Theismann, Washington's Super Bowl-winning quarterback in the 1982 season and another supporter of the name. "It's an election year."

Possible Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton has called it "insensitive." Fifty Democratic senators equated the name to "racism and bigotry." Maryland Gov. Martin O'Malley, who is mulling a run for president, said it is "probably time" for the name to change. President Barack Obama said he would "think about changing" the name if he owned the team.

But the politicians were late-comers. A confluence of events — and several missteps by Snyder and his organization — has made the issue a topic du jour.

It started with a February 2013 symposium on mascot history at the Smithsonian that left a 20-year-old Redskins fan so embarrassed that he took over his team gear and said: "I really don't feel right wearing this stuff now."

That was soon followed by the latest hearing in a long-running case brought by a group of Native Americans intent on stripping the team of its trademark protection — the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office eventually ruled against the Redskins, but the case will likely be tied up in the courts for years. Then, last spring, the opposition got an unexpected boost from Snyder himself. The owner has always vowed never to change the name, but he came across as especially strident when he told USA Today: "We'll never change the name. It's that simple. NEVER — you can use caps."

Soon, the Oneida Indian Nation in New York had joined the fray as a major player, buying television and radio ads in major markets — including one that ran during the NBA finals. Now, every time the team does anything to promote the name, Oneida counters with a news release within minutes. The anti-"Redskins" coalition never had an ally like it.

"They really put a lot of effort and personal time — and the important thing, money — into what we were doing," said Suzan Shown Harjo, a longtime lead figure in the trademark case. "We've never had money before. We've always done this on a wing and a prayer."

When Snyder started an Original Americans Foundation to give financial support to Native American tribes, Harjo called it "somewhere between a PR assault and bribery." When a major sector of the United Church of Christ was preparing a vote to boycott the Redskins, the team tried to make its case by having three self-identified members of the Blackfeet Nation call church leader Rev. John Deckenback on the phone, but Deckenback said the three didn't really push the team's cause and called the interaction a "somewhat weird experience."

Try out the new DeseretNews.com design!
try beta learn more
Get The Deseret News Everywhere