Frank Pignanelli & LaVarr Webb: What is Utah's 'secret sauce' for a good economy?

Published: Sunday, Aug. 25 2013 12:00 a.m. MDT

Columnists Pignanelli and Webb examine how events, people and trends of the past 12 months have influenced Utah politics.

Mike Terry, Deseret News

Enlarge photo»

Random answers to random questions:

Utah's congressional delegation, led by Rep. Rob Bishop, R-Utah, and his staff member Fred Ferguson, is making an unprecedented effort to forge a "grand bargain" to solve long-standing public lands disputes. It could result in additional wilderness designation in Utah, along with more energy development. Does this initiative have a chance to succeed?

Pignanelli: "Bargaining has neither friends nor relations" — Benjamin Franklin

"Grand bargains" between special interests are the bedrock of this country. The Constitution is stuffed with them, and they provide the structure for all significant legislation adopted since the inception of this republic. When Congress ultimately decides to accomplish something, grand bargains will dictate changes to entitlement programs, regulatory schemes and ending budget deficits.

Until recently, Bishop was unable to say the words "wilderness designation" without a massive smirk. So his efforts, and those of Rep. Jason Chaffetz, R-Utah, to structure a compromise are significant. Equally eye-opening is the willingness of Scott Groene (director of Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance) to meet with these conservatives. The level of hostility among the negotiating parties is only outmatched by the violent emotions between Israelis and Palestinians. Mistrust and a long history of antagonism could inhibit success. But if a grand bargain is reached, these three must be shipped to the Middle East to spread their charm.

Webb: So far, so good — but the trickiest part is still ahead. Bishop and other members of the delegation have worked incredibly hard to bring every interest group together to try to find common ground, including many groups that have been enemies for decades.

What makes this effort different is that Bishop is appealing to the selfish interests of all parties: "Get more of what you want by giving up something of value to someone else." He's telling rural counties to trade additional wilderness for more energy development, roads and other things they need. He's telling environmental groups to allow energy development and other land uses on the sagebrush flats and hills of the Uintah Basin, in exchange for more wilderness in pristine, scenic areas.

The test will come when lines start being drawn on maps. It's all very fragile. Almost any interest group could kill the whole thing. Legislation will have to survive a very conservative Republican House and a Democratic Senate — and have the support of the Obama administration.

Utah's economy continues to outpace most other states. What is Utah's "secret sauce" that keeps our economy humming?

Pignanelli: LaVarr is an active Mormon, and therefore much too nice to offer a direct answer to this question. Conversely, I am a drinking, swearing heathen without discretion (to my mother's shame) and will provide the honest reply. The LDS Church principles, its members and unique history of our state are most of the ingredients to the formula that maintains the magic of this wondrous place to live and work. Almost 70 percent of Utahns adhere to a faith that emphasizes education, hard work, frugality, efficient planning, respect for authority, interest in the arts and focus on the family. Add these components into a historical psyche of hungering to prove we are just as good as anyone else, and you have a concoction that breeds sound business performance. Nonmembers who live here long enough share this persona. Utah is exceptional, because no one else has our heritage.

Get The Deseret News Everywhere

Subscribe

Mobile

RSS