Phelan M. Ebenhack, Associated Press
Justice is supposed to be the American way. But the acquittal of George Zimmerman in the killing of Trayvon Martin has revealed two starkly different visions of what Americans think justice should be.
What is justice for Martin — the 17-year-old black youth, mourned by many as a victim who was minding his own business when he fell under misplaced suspicion? What is justice for Zimmerman, seen by many others as a good neighbor who made a fatal mistake?
The national conversation over the verdict shows two sides talking about two different things: either the two minutes when Zimmerman and Martin fought face to face, or the centuries of racial context that many believe caused a senseless death.
The debate also has revealed deep resistance to the idea that justice in this case might not be black and white, but could include a gray area with important parts of both visions.
"Is justice getting the bad guy?" asks Gene Demby, who writes about race for National Public Radio's "Code Switch" blog.
"So many of us," he says, "have very different ideas of what the bad guys look like."
Martin and Zimmerman each thought he was the good guy on a rainy night in February 2012.
Zimmerman, a Hispanic neighborhood watch volunteer, spotted Martin, who was simply walking home from the store wearing a hoodie. Zimmerman called police to report a "suspicious" person "up to no good." Martin, on his cell phone, told a friend that a "creepy-ass cracker" was following him. They fought — testimony differed regarding who was on top of whom — and then Zimmerman shot Martin once in the chest.
Zimmerman said he killed Martin in self-defense. A jury of six women — five white, one described as Hispanic, none black — found him not guilty of second-degree murder or manslaughter.
Among the things jurors were instructed to consider was whether Zimmerman believed he was in severe danger during the fight with Martin. What led to the fight was not the issue, according to the only juror who has spoken publicly.
The juror, who did not allow her name to be used, told CNN that Zimmerman didn't use "good judgment" and he shouldn't have gotten out of his car. But she believes that Martin attacked Zimmerman, and that he had a right to defend himself.
Says Richard Lowry, editor of the National Review, the conservative magazine: "It was a terrible tragedy, it never should have happened, Zimmerman showed awful judgment, it has placed an unspeakable burden on the Martin family — but it just wasn't a crime."
Glen Weekley, a software salesman from Georgia, says Zimmerman may have profiled Martin.
"But that does not go back to the core issue of whether justice was served. Of course it was. It's completely illogical to say anything else," Weekley says. "He was not on trial for confronting him or profiling him or following him."
This view of justice is focused narrowly on the two minutes that Zimmerman and Martin fought. Guided by the law, this view excludes everything before those fleeting seconds — such as the belief that Zimmerman thought Martin was suspicious because he was black.
Those who decry the verdict want a broad justice that accounts for how race affects society. They think justice should hold Zimmerman accountable for causing the fatal encounter by racially profiling Martin, then following him against the instructions of the police dispatcher.
"The justice system is essentially saying that context doesn't matter," says George Ciccariello-Maher, a history and politics professor at Drexel University. "It's not illegal to be a racist stalker — that's extraneous to the legal question of self-defense."
- Chaffetz expected to announce he's running...
- Guatemalan mudslide death toll reaches 69,...
- Veteran who tried to stop Oregon gunman was...
- Trump defends 2nd Amendment following Oregon...
- More police refusing to name shooters for...
- Hatch calls shutting down government over...
- 'A terrible day' - 9 killed by gunman in...
- Oregon gunman was Army dropout who studied...
- Hatch calls shutting down government... 67
- Gunman opens fire at Oregon college; at... 62
- 'A terrible day' - 9 killed by gunman... 61
- Investigation: Secret Service tried to... 52
- Obama says response to shootings has... 49
- Chaffetz expected to announce he's... 49
- GOP: Planned Parenthood spends federal... 45
- Obama says fight against Islamic State... 26