Frank Pignanelli & LaVarr Webb: The future of same-sex marriage and immigration

Published: Sunday, July 14 2013 12:00 a.m. MDT

Traditional marriage supporters and same-sex marriage supporters gather at Tuesday, March 26, 2013, at the state Capitol in Salt Lake City.

Scott G Winterton, Deseret News

Enlarge photo»

Utah summers are wonderful, with picnics and cooling off at the pool. But even amid the sunshine, politicos gather in dark corners to ponder current events. Here are some discussion topics:

Before its summer recess, the U.S. Supreme Court dropped a few bombs on proponents of traditional marriage, gutting the federal Defense of Marriage Act and refusing to revive California's Proposition 8 — effectively reinstituting same-sex marriage in that state. The net effect is tossing the issue for states to decide, and activists on both sides are gearing up for more battles. How does this play out in Utah?

Pignanelli: "I was against gay marriage until I realized I didn't have to get one." — James Carville

In the near future, there will be some noise — perhaps a lawsuit — but not much activity (a selfish desire because protest marches add 5 minutes to my commute). Long term is different.

Polls indicate most Utahns — especially under 30 — support civil unions/domestic partnerships for gay and lesbian couples. State officials are extraordinarily successful in recruiting businesses to relocate operations to the Beehive State. But soon companies will ask whether the benefits they provide to gay and lesbian employees can exist under Utah law. While the prohibition of marriage may not be problematic, barring any unions between employees and partners (which our constitution does) will be an issue for large enterprises. Economic development and jobs will be on the line.

Both of these dynamics will increase in intensity. Therefore, I predict that by the end of the decade the Utah Constitution will be amended to allow civil unions and domestic partnerships.

Webb: Utah's constitutional protection of traditional marriage will remain in force for many years, but the national trend is clearly in favor of same-sex marriage. Policymakers should keep the fundamentals in mind: The family is the basic unit of society, crucial to strong communities, a strong nation and individual happiness. Policies that strengthen families should be pursued.

The U.S. Senate passed immigration reform with Utah's two senators splitting their votes. Now it's the House's turn to act. How will Utah's House delegation respond to pressure from business and community groups favoring comprehensive reform?

Pignanelli: The immigration debate is highlighting how the delegate/convention system empowers a minority of tyrants to defeat the will of the populace. A majority of Utahns support the immigration legislation. Every major business, agricultural, technology, religious and charitable organization endorses the bill. Any group that boasts rational humans as members has embraced it. But their pressure is diminished.

State delegates are only .002 percent of the voting age population but control the convention and nomination process. Our congressional delegation cannot ignore this reality and must pay deference to their demands, regardless of how absurd. Proponents of reform should consider shifting the artillery toward political party officials.

Webb: As I've written previously, Congress spends way too much time sticking its nose into all sorts of things where it has no business. But immigration policy is an unambiguous federal responsibility. Congress suffers its lowest approval ratings in history. This is a test of Congress' ability to get anything done. Every member of Congress agrees the current system is broken and needs to be fixed. If they can't fix this, they might as well resign and slink home in shame.

The Senate has passed an immigration package with serious flaws but also some very good provisions. It's not perfect, but it's a lot better than the status quo. Ideally, the House would fix the Senate flaws and produce something even better. Utah's business and community leaders, plus the vast majority of citizens want real results. We'll see if they have courage to do the right thing.

Try out the new DeseretNews.com design!
try beta learn more
Get The Deseret News Everywhere