Scott G. Winterton, Dnews
Richard Davis' column of Jan. 23, "Ways to make the Electoral College more fair," resonates with me. (I like the "more fair" part.) The Electoral College, instituted to keep the populous urban areas from dominating the less populous areas, is necessary and there should be no discussion to replace it. But each state can change its process, and more fair is desirable.
The current "winner-take-all" method (in 48 states) is unfair as it disenfranchises up to 50 percent of the voters and still favors the urban areas. Consider, if you are a Republican in blue-state California or a Democrat in red-state Utah, why even bother to cast a vote for president?
The Nebraska and Maine models, to which Davis referred, would have resulted in a "more fair" 2012 presidential election, more representative of the nation rather than the lopsided result of Obama – 332, Romney – 206 (61 percent to 38 percent).
Under the Nebraska/Maine model, Electoral College votes would be allocated by two criteria: on the basis of congressional districts, with two votes per state allocated on the basis of the popular vote in the state. This is a more fair approach. It slightly reduces the over-weighting of concentrated voting in high density urban areas, and more fairly represents the country as a whole.
David S. Hullinger
- In our opinion: Paul Ryan's promising...
- Carmen Rasmusen Herbert: Becoming mentally...
- Involve Utahns in national monument designations
- Letter: Welfare reform
- Legitimate, productive businesses are...
- Perceptions of Obama and his policies at home...
- My view: Utah's Constitution requires state...
- In our opinion: Federal contracting executive...
- In our opinion: The Affordable Care Act... 80
- Can a news channel 'solve problems'? 54
- In our opinion: Paul Ryan's promising... 53
- In our opinion: The long-term outlook... 51
- Capitalism and the common good:... 45
- Join the discussion: Is feminism... 39
- In our opinion: Timing is right for the... 39
- My view: A global warming solution to... 36