What others say: Evaluating teachers

Chicago Tribune

Published: Tuesday, Jan. 15 2013 12:00 a.m. MST

Teacher Heidi Hummel is evaluated by the school principal while teaching kindergarten at Harry S. Truman Elementary in West Valley City. Harry S. Truman Elementary principal Tyler Howe says the teachers' union helped set up the school's evaluation technique. Principal Tyler Howe makes notes as he observes sixth-grade teacher Toni Martin's interaction with students.

Ravell Call, Deseret News

Enlarge photo»

The following editorial appeared recently in the Chicago Tribune:

For years, educators have argued about the best ways to grade teachers' performance in the classroom. Some skeptics doubted it was possible to fairly evaluate teachers, partly because some teachers had brighter students while others faced classes filled with struggling kids.

That argument should end, thanks to a blockbuster new study from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.

Researchers tracked 3,000 teachers in Dallas, New York, Charlotte, N.C., and elsewhere over three years. They found that the most effective teachers can spur test scores of students who had lagged under less effective teachers. Most important: The best teachers produced test score and other academic gains even when students were randomly assigned to their classrooms.

In other words, this research tells us that good teachers can help all students, not just those who excel naturally. Key point: Researchers showed they could reliably identify those teachers and predict their impact on student learning.

A combination of three measures yield the most accurate evaluations, according to the study:

Students' progress on standardized tests. That is the so-called "value-added" formula that shows how much a teacher catapults a student's academic growth or sets it back. The study says student growth should be a third to a half of a teacher's evaluation.

Careful observations of teachers in front of their classes, either by principals or other trained observers.

Surveys of students about what goes on in the classroom. Unsurprising conclusion: Kids often know which teachers are most effective.

Those three factors produced a result "teachers can trust," Vicki Phillips, a director in the education program at the Gates Foundation, told reporters.

That's a vital message to all teachers, principals and parents.

Across Illinois, many school districts are planning to roll out new evaluation systems. State law says student growth must account for at least 25 percent of a teacher's evaluation in the first two years, rising to at least 30 percent thereafter.

Many of the details, however, are left to administrators and union leaders to hash out in new labor contracts. In last year's CPS contract, for instance, Chicago Teachers Union officials tried but, fortunately for students, failed to water down CPS' new teacher evaluation system, which roughly follows the Gates model.

For principals, teachers and parents across the state, the Gates study provides compelling evidence of how teachers may be fairly judged.

These systems, however, still depend on buy-in from principals and teachers. And many districts in the state are still dawdling. That's why Illinois hasn't been freed by the U.S. Department of Education to craft its own academic benchmarks to boost student achievement and avoid sanctions for falling short of No Child Left Behind standards.

The Gates study should give Illinois educators confidence to accelerate progress and set these gold-standard evaluation systems in place. We know how to identify and reward the best teachers. And we know the result: Kids learn.

Get The Deseret News Everywhere

Subscribe

Mobile

RSS