Quantcast

'No Easy Day' a compelling account of Bin Laden's killing

By Tony Perry

Los Angeles Times (MCT)

Published: Saturday, Sept. 8 2012 3:00 p.m. MDT

"NO EASY DAY: THE FIRSTHAND ACCOUNT OF THE MISSION THAT KILLED OSAMA BIN LADEN," by Mark Owen with Kevin Maurer; Dutton, 315 pages, $26.95 (nf)

Former Navy SEAL Matt Bissonnette did not put the first slug into Osama bin Laden when SEALs raided the terrorist's lair in Pakistan last year in May.

But he fired follow-up shots quickly and without remorse, as he describes in vivid, gruesome detail in "No Easy Day," written under the pseudonym Mark Owen with co-author Kevin Maurer.

Within minutes, the SEALs had identified the dead man as Bin Laden. A coded phrase was relayed to an admiral in Afghanistan, who flashed the news to a waiting President Obama: The mission to get Bin Laden, at long last, had been accomplished. Obama's gamble to green-light the assault, rather than an aerial bombing raid, had paid off.

Make no mistake: "No Easy Day" is an important historic document. Think if we had a first-person account of the last minutes of Hitler in his bunker or Yamamoto on his plane.

There will be other accounts of this mission, and maybe some will dispute key details of "No Easy Day." Anyone who has been in a traffic accident or witnessed a street crime knows that eyewitnesses can disagree sharply.

Still, "No Easy Day" is brisk and compelling in its telling of the training, execution and immediate aftermath of the Bin Laden mission by the elite Seal Team 6 — no easy task since the public already knows how it ended, with Bin Laden dead, no U.S. casualties and the Pakistanis furious that the U.S. had invaded their country.

The Pentagon has threatened Bissonnette with legal action for supposedly breaking a secrecy agreement demanded of all SEALs. Whether that is a real threat or just institutional huff-and-puff remains to be seen.

Bissonnette has gone to lengths to avoid disclosing trade secrets about gathering intelligence and assaulting barricaded structures. And his first-name-only descriptions are so careful that you would not know one of the SEALs if he was standing next to you in the grocery store, although use of the word "dude," the phrase "the teams" and, of course, the F-word would be tipoffs.

Security aside, blandness is a problem. Couldn't the reader have been given at least some description of the SEAL who fired the shot as Bin Laden peeked out of his third-floor bedroom? Why did he fire at an unarmed subject? Did his fellow SEALs, known for hard-edge ribbing, give him a bad time later for possibly violating the order that the mission was not meant to be an assassination?

And what about pumping bullets into Bin Laden as he lay defenseless on the floor? Doesn't the Geneva Convention require the rendering of aid to even the most despicable of wounded combatants? Or do such rules not apply to U.S. special forces? Possibly to avoid such inconvenient questions, the White House insisted bin Laden was killed in a firefight.

With the additional subtitle of "The Autobiography of a Navy SEAL," Bissonnette's book says he grew up in Alaska and attended college in California (no names provided). He loved the physical challenge and the camaraderie of being a SEAL: That's a story well-known to any consumer of SEAL books or SEAL documentaries.

If Bissonnette has any special insight into the war in Afghanistan or the use of special forces against an insurgency, he has kept it to himself. There is some grousing about desk-bound officers and the politicians in Washington, but nothing you would not hear from the average enlisted rank.

For all the planning, the mission was not flawless. One of the helicopters crashed. Special spring-loaded syringes given to the SEALs by the CIA to get blood-marrow samples failed to work. Because of miscommunication, an explosives expert came close to blowing up the compound where Bin Laden, his family members and guards lived.

But these are quibbles. The mission, from the U.S. perspective, was a spectacular success, and "No Easy Day" renders in dramatic fashion those tense minutes in Abbottabad in May 2011. The dominant tone of the book is one of cool detachment, a perfectionist describing a day (actually, a night) at the office. Only when Bissonnette looks down at Bin Laden in a widening pool of blood does he permit himself an expression of disgust:

"He had no intention of fighting. He asked his followers for decades to wear suicide vests or fly planes into buildings but didn't even pick up his weapon. In all of my deployments, we routinely saw this phenomenon …," he writes, adding, "The leaders were less willing to fight. It is always the young and impressionable who strap on the explosives and blow themselves up."

Get The Deseret News Everywhere

Subscribe

Mobile

RSS