Choosing between Luck, Griffin was tough call

By Michael Marot

Associated Press

Published: Saturday, April 21 2012 12:00 a.m. MDT

"Just that I can make NFL throws," he said then. "Whether it's timing, the skinny post to the right, the quick out or the deep ball. Just tried to cover all the bases."

Griffin's resume is every bit as impressive.

In 2011, the Texas prep star who opted to stay home for college, threw for 4,293 yards, 37 TDs, completed 72.4 percent of his passes and threw just six interceptions — better numbers than Luck. His incredible mobility drew raves, too.

And after throwing for 479 yards and four TDs in a win that knocked Oklahoma out of the national title chase, Griffin burst onto the national scene as a Heisman contender. Eventually, he beat Luck in that one.

But NFL scouts knew Griffin was a star much earlier.

"RG3 was an unknown quantity to those outside the professional scouting community. So his 'ride; was purely a result of those who didn't know him," Polian said. "He hasn't risen, he was there all the time. Anybody who tells you he wasn't, wasn't doing their homework."

Like Luck, Griffin has demonstrated there's more to life than football.

At the 2011 NCAA convention, NCAA president Mark Emmert singled out Griffin as an example of a model student-athlete.

Griffin earned his political science degree in three years, graduating in 2010. He was regular on Baylor's dean's list and still has aspirations of attending law school. He was fast enough to qualify for the 2008 Olympics trials semifinals in the 400-meter hurdles and passionate enough about volunteering to find time to help five charities.

So when Griffin decided to leave school early, it was because he felt it was time — not because of the money.

"Sometimes you just have that feeling, and I had it after the bowl game," Griffin said when he declared for the draft after resuscitating Baylor's football program. "Like I said, it's been real exciting here at Baylor, it's been a lot of fun. And in life, that's what you try to do, you try to be happy, you try to have a lot of fun."

The Redskins think Griffin is a perfect fit in Washington, right down to that political science degree.

GM Bruce Allen and coach Mike Shanahan were so convinced about Griffin's ability that they paid a hefty price to get a shot at him. They traded this year's first and second-round picks and first-rounders in each of the next two years to St. Louis to move up four spots to get either Luck or Griffin.

Shanahan understands what that kind of move that can do for a franchise. He won two Super Bowls with Elway in Denver, but hasn't been back to the NFL's big game since Elway retired after the 1998 season. Griffin could be just the guy to change that.

"You get someone you feel like can be a franchise quarterback for years to come, that doesn't happen very often," Shanahan said at the recent league meetings. "To have that guy — they're hard to find."

The next debate will be about who is more ready to win?

Luck has drawn the obvious comparisons to Elway and has been called the most NFL-ready quarterback since Manning entered the league in 1998.

Oliver Luck, Andrew's dad, insists the extra year has made his son a better, more mature quarterback.

"I think he grew in his role as a QB, I think he played in a little bit of fish bowl because of the expectations, which I think is great training for the NFL," he said.

However, Polian thinks Griffin will win the next round.

"I believe without question, both will be successful," Polian said. "I believe Andrew may struggle early simply because of the surrounding cast playing with him. It was nowhere near where Peyton's was and he went 3-13. I think Andrew will struggle more because of the receivers around him. Only Reggie (Wayne) and Austin (Collie) are back. RGIII is going to be adapting to a new offense. In spite of that, he may have the easier road in his rookie year. Having said that, they'll both struggle, but that doesn't change my opinion. I think both will be successful."


Associated Press Sports Writers Antonio Gonzalez in San Francisco, Stephen Hawkins in Dallas and Joseph White in Washington also contributed to this report.

Try out the new DeseretNews.com design!
try beta learn more
Get The Deseret News Everywhere