Hamm and twin brother Morgan, from Waukesha, Wis., were considered phenoms when they burst onto the scene in 1999, finishing 11th and 16th, respectively at the U.S. championships, despite being just 16. In 2000, Paul had jumped to third at nationals, and he and Morgan made their first Olympic team. He gave a hint in Sydney of what was to come, posting the sixth-best qualifying score and making the all-around finals before he'd even finished high school.
With immaculate lines and body position, and a polish that commanded attention, Hamm had an elegance no other gymnast could match, and he was as fierce a competitor as any athlete in any sport. His comeback in Athens was almost inconceivable. After a fall on vault dropped him to 12th place with only two events left, he rallied with two of the best routines of his career to win the gold.
"It was amazing," Hamm said. "It was the highlight of my life."
Added Vidmar: "Winning it is one of great moments in USA gymnastics. It's hard enough to win a world title, but to win the world title and the Olympic title back to back, that doesn't happen very often."
Two days later, however, the International Gymnastics Federation said bronze medalist Yang Tae-young of South Korea had been wrongly docked a tenth of a point on his second-to-last event. Add that extra tenth, and Yang would have scored higher than Hamm.
That assumes, however, that everything in the final rotation would have played out the same, something nobody can say for sure.
The Koreans also did not protest in time, and the FIG said it couldn't change results after the competition. But the Koreans took the matter all the way to the Court of Arbitration for Sport, and many — including the president of international gymnastics' governing body — suggested Hamm give up his medal.
Instead of celebrating the achievement of a lifetime, Hamm wound up defending it, despite having done nothing wrong.
Two months after the Olympics ended, CAS declared Hamm the rightful gold medalist. FIG president Bruno Grandi has since said the American deserved to be Olympic champion.
"I'm able to just look back at the gymnastics and the performance and remember it for a great thing," Hamm said. "I understand the things that happened in my life, it's just a part of the whole story. But overall, I feel the journey I had in the sport of gymnastics was a tremendous journey and very productive for me and my life, and the person I've become."
Hamm and his brother took 2½ years off after Athens, enrolling at Ohio State and living as normal college students. Despite the layoff — almost unheard of in a sport where heavy doses of repetition are the key to maintaining that all-important muscle memory — Hamm returned in 2007 and quickly established himself as a contender for another gold, winning every meet he entered in 2008, often by large margins.
But he broke a bone in his right hand at the U.S. championships, just 11 weeks before the Beijing Olympics. He earned a spot on the Olympic team, but the hand and an injured shoulder forced him to withdraw a few weeks before the games. He announced another comeback in July 2010 but tore his right labrum and rotator cuff in early 2011.
Just as his shoulder was on the mend, he was arrested in September, accused of hitting and kicking a cab driver, damaging the taxi's window and refusing to pay a $23 fare. It was an embarrassing episode for Hamm, whose discipline and composed focus was as much his trademark as his superb skills. He pleaded no contest to two reduced charges, both misdemeanors, last month. A misdemeanor assault charge was dismissed.
With the court case resolved, Hamm was eager to turn all of his focus to London. But his body simply wouldn't cooperate.
"You just keep pushing a little bit and realize, 'This is getting really hard,'" he said. "I slowly started to spend less time in the gym, and that's when the decision was truly made. If I'm really training for the Olympics, I'm not taking a day off here and there."
Hamm, who has a degree in accounting, recently was accepted into the MBA program at Marquette University for next fall. He's already talked to USA Gymnastics about trying to help the men's team prepare for London, and Penny said they are eager to take advantage of Hamm's knowledge and experience.
Hamm eventually will have to file paperwork to make his retirement official but said there is no rush. Asked if that meant the door was still open to come back, Hamm laughed, then said no.
"(Retiring) is disappointing. But at the same time, I'm happy with my decision. I'm happy to move on to different things," he said. "There's a lot to life besides gymnastics."
Follow Nancy Armour at www.twitter.com/nrarmour
- National experts weigh in on the BYU Cougars'...
- Rock On: Next Utah college coach to leave is ...
- Gordon Hayward looks to get better at...
- Rock On: Next Utah college coach to leave is ...
- Analysis: Utah Jazz will be better, but will...
- High school track: Top performances from 2015
- 2015 Deseret News NFL Mock Draft: Wide...
- Amy Donaldson: South Summit High community...
- Little offense as main players sit out... 105
- Brad Rock: BYU's window is closing; big... 101
- Morning links: Duke in pursuit of Lone... 45
- BYU offense looking to move the ball,... 34
- Analysis: Utah Jazz will be better, but... 17
- Dave Rose hires May as BYU's director... 13
- Pittsburgh to hire Utah State Athletic... 11
- Scott Mitchell: Former U., NFL... 10