Israel policy of detaining kids questioned

By Diaa Hadid

Associated Press

Published: Saturday, March 17 2012 2:55 a.m. MDT

In this March 12, 2012 photograph, Mahmoud al-Alami, 10, left, stands in front of his home with his cousin Farah, center, and brother Mamoun in Beit Umar, West Bank. When Mahmoud was 9-years-old, an Israeli soldier caught him throwing rocks, took him out of his uncle's arms, slung him over his shoulders and took him away. Mahmoud says he was subsequently blindfolded and shackled, slapped and ordered to confess to throwing rocks at Israeli soldiers and identify other children doing the same.

Diaa Hadid, Associated Press

Enlarge photo»

BEIT UMAR, West Bank — When Mahmoud al-Alami was 9 years old, an Israeli soldier caught him throwing rocks, took him out of his uncle's arms, slung him over his shoulders and carried him away.

Mahmoud, now 10, says he was subsequently blindfolded and shackled, slapped and ordered to confess to throwing rocks at Israeli soldiers and identify other children doing the same.

Mahmoud is among dozens of Palestinian minors who are detained every month by Israeli security forces in the West Bank and Arab neighborhoods of east Jerusalem, interrogated and pressured to report on others, according to a report issued this week.

The report, by the Swedish branch of the organization Save the Children and the East Jerusalem YMCA, examined the cases of 297 minors aged 17 and under who were detained in 2011, most of them in nighttime raids on their homes after Israeli forces accused them of throwing stones.

The detentions are drawing criticism from human rights groups, which say they traumatize the children and violate their rights. Rights activists say Israel appears to use detentions to scare young children into not throwing rocks again, as well as to extract information about older rock-hurling youths. They say interrogators also gather evidence against Palestinian leaders of weekly demonstrations that take place around the West Bank. The demonstrations often turn into confrontations between rock-throwing youths and Israeli soldiers firing tear gas and rubber bullets.

Israel's military points out that rocks Palestinian youths throw can be dangerous and even deadly. In September, an Israeli settler and his year-old son were killed in a car cash after stones were thrown at their vehicle on a highway that crosses the West Bank.

"It doesn't matter if it was thrown by a 12-year-old or a 20-year-old if it killed somebody," said an officer in Israel's military justice system, speaking on condition of anonymity under briefing regulations. "We still have to take minors to trial. It's still a serious offense for us."

Mahmoud denies he was throwing stones at soldiers when he was detained for several hours in February last year. He says he was hurling rocks at friends pretending to be Israeli soldiers — a game the children call "Arabs and Jews" — near a military watchtower in his home village of Beit Umar. Nearby soldiers thought he was targeting them, he said.

"It was just a game," the fifth-grader said.

The soldiers chased the children, and Mahmoud ran into the arms of his uncle, who has a mental disability, before soldiers pulled him away. The boy was held from around noon until late evening. His mother says he still has nightmares that the soldiers will return.

The Israeli official said the army does not hold children under 12. Asked to explained Mahmoud's detention, he said it's possible the boy was questioned until interrogators found out his age. He said minors are now tried in a special youth court, and that proceedings are sped up.

Most minors never make it to trial because they usually agree to plea bargains that their lawyers tell them will reduce their sentences. Few Palestinian youths, or their lawyers, believe they will receive a fair trial.

From 2005 through 2010, 834 minors 17 and younger were brought before Israeli military courts on stone-throwing charges, according to the Israeli rights group B'tselem. Of these, 288 — around a third — were between 12 and 15 years old. All but one were found guilty, mostly in plea bargains, and spent a few weeks to a few months in jail.

Rights activists say the interrogations of children and use of their confessions are particularly problematic.

Get The Deseret News Everywhere

Subscribe

Mobile

RSS