Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez's admission that he will undergo new cancer surgery raises a whole set of new questions about the viability of his narcissist-Leninist "revolution" both at home and throughout Latin America.
Many of us who thought that Chavez would win the Oct. 7 elections thanks to a combination of a massive use of state resources to buy votes, a virtual monopoly of the air-waves and intimidation of opposition voters will have to rethink our forecasts. Chavez may still win, but it's not that sure anymore.
Chavez's admission that his cancer treatment will slow him down — "I can't keep up this pace," he said Tuesday — and the massive show of support for 39-year-old presidential candidate Henrique Capriles Radonski in the Feb. 12 opposition primary elections are two factors that are bound to have a big impact on the presidential race.
All of a sudden, Chavez has lost his aura of invincibility. Venezuelan political insiders are no longer discussing whether Chavez will stay in power "beyond 2019" — as he claimed as recently as Feb. 18 — but whether he will be president by the end of this year.
There are three major scenarios of what may happen in Venezuela in coming months:
Scenario 1: Nothing changes. Chavez slows down his campaign, but remains on the ballot for the October presidential elections.
Chavez could win, if — in addition to around-the-clock propaganda and intimidation campaigns — his government benefits from a big rise in oil prices from a potential Israeli attack on Iran's nuclear facilities. That would give the Venezuelan government extra cash to hand out to voters.
Also, the "pity effect" of Venezuelans who may feel emotionally closer to an ailing leader could help Chavez at the ballot box, although such feelings may now be offset by anger over the president's clumsy denials of rumors about his health that turned out to be true.
Scenario 2: Chavez appoints a successor. Chavez's health deteriorates, and — pretty much like Cuba's Fidel Castro did when he announced July 31, 2006, that he would undergo surgery and was provisionally ceding his powers to his brother Raul — the Venezuelan president appoints a substitute to run in the October elections.
Cuba, which relies heavily on Chavez's petrodollars and is most concerned about maintaining the status quo in Venezuela, will be the first to recommend its own Fidel-to-Raul succession model to Chavez, in which Chavez would remain a largely behind-the-scenes "father of the revolution."
Still, without Chavez's constant presence in the media, his successor could lose the October elections. Polls show that Chavez is much more popular than his notoriously corrupt and inept government. In addition, electoral trends in recent years have shown steady gains for the opposition: anti-Chavez candidates won 52 percent of the vote in the 2010 legislative elections, and got an unexpectedly high 3 million votes in this month's opposition primaries.
Scenario 3: A military intervention, or "the Egyptian scenario." Chavez becomes incapacitated or dies in coming months, and the likelihood of an opposition victory in the October elections moves the Venezuelan military to create a provisional government, claiming that the country has become ungovernable.
Chavez's top generals would have the most to lose if the regime falls. Some of the generals, including Defense Minister Gen. Henry Rangel Silva, are wanted by U.S. law enforcement agencies on drug trafficking charges, while others fear corruption probes if the opposition wins the elections.
"To avoid losing power, the military may claim that the country is on the verge of a supposed civil war and intervene," says Caracas-based public affairs consultant and pollster Alfredo Keller. "If Chavez disappears, an Egyptian scenario is highly possible."
My opinion: Any of these three scenarios is possible, but in the interest of preserving what is left of Venezuelan democracy, the Obama administration and Latin American governments should warn Venezuela's military that they will not accept an "Egyptian scenario."
The last thing Latin America needs following the steady erosion of democratic freedoms in Venezuela, Nicaragua, Bolivia, Ecuador and other countries in recent years is a return of military juntas. The first two scenarios — no matter who wins — is preferable to the third one.
Andres Oppenheimer is a Latin America correspondent for the Miami Herald. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org.
- About Utah: He walked around the lake —...
- Jay Evensen: On Second Thought: Stephen...
- In our opinion: Incentives in welfare reform...
- Letter: Troubling scenario
- John Hoffmire: Climate change...
- In our opinion: Train terrorism incident in...
- Letter: Address a growing threat
- Frank Pignanelli & LaVarr Webb: As summer...