Bill could prevent 'open-carry' gun owners from facing criminal charges

SALT LAKE CITY — A bill proposed for the 2012 Utah Legislature would prohibit a person who is lawfully carrying a firearm in public from being charged with non-firearm related crimes such as disorderly conduct or disturbing the operation of a school.

HB49, sponsored by Rep. Paul Ray, R-Clearfield, states that, “… in the absence of additional threatening behavior, the otherwise lawful possession of a firearm … whether visible or concealed” would not in itself constitute a violation of various criminal statutes.

The statutes specified by the bill also include failure to leave a higher education campus when ordered, failure to disperse, disrupting a meeting or procession, threatening with or using a dangerous weapon in a fight, and several others, according to the current version of the bill.

The initial version of the bill is only a very rough draft and Ray said he is working with gun rights advocates, prosecutors and others to create an extensive revision.

“What you’re seeing isn’t what you’re going to get,” he said.

Ray expects the new version of the “Firearms Revisions” bill to be completed late this week.

The bill’s purpose is to clarify when a person lawfully carrying a gun in public, concealed or not, might be charged with disorderly conduct or other crimes that are not explicitly gun-related.  

For example, if someone with a permit is carrying a concealed weapon and it inadvertently becomes visible, could they be charged with brandishing a weapon?

The impetus for the bill stems from a January incident at University Mall in Orem, he said. On Jan. 15, Philip W. Taylor, a 51-year-old Orem man, was walking along the sidewalk adjacent to the mall with an assault rifle slung over his back and carrying a handgun.

Orem police responded to the scene after receiving several 911 calls from alarmed shoppers.

An officer approached Taylor and ordered him: “Keep your hands where I can see them.”

Taylor responded, “Utah is open carry, officer.”

Asked why he had a gun on him, Taylor again replied, “Utah is open carry.”

“Not open carry for an assault rifle,” the officer replied.

Taylor was handcuffed and detained for a few minutes, while officers determined the guns were unloaded.