Risky venture: Copper mining in Milford brimming with high hopes, fears of failure
'Potential payoff is huge' if mineral can be extracted, investors believe
MILFORD, Beaver County — Millions, perhaps billions, or — gasp! — trillions of dollars might lie under the sage brush covered hills surrounding this middle-of-nowhere, going-nowhere town.
Maybe that's why this declining southwestern Utah backwater has drawn interest from thousands of speculators, a celebrity or two and an international playboy who was once photographed with the Duchess of York in a compromising position.
There's copper in those hills. Lots of it, apparently. Gold and silver, too. Not to mention other possibly lucrative minerals. This fact is not new. It has been known for at least a century.
But the most recent effort to extract those precious metals resulted in large debts and bad feelings, not to mention loads of alleged Securities and Exchange Commission violations.
Mayor Bryan Sherwood, who is in the middle of tearing down dilapidated Main Street buildings, winces at the rise and fall of Copper King Mining Corp.
Outside the Circle Four hog farm and Heritage Plastics, jobs in the high-desert town of 1,600 are scarce. Once a key stop on the Union Pacific Railroad line 230 miles southwest of Salt Lake City, Milford has little to attract anyone these days.
"Having that mine open would help everything," Sherwood says.
Efforts to salvage the bankrupt company took a turn last week when a dogged shareholders committee attempted to take control of the four-member board of directors. The committee wants to put into place its own people, including two mining experts.
"These guys are real rock busters," said Florida investor Dave Wright.
The proposed board appears headed for a showdown with the current CEO for control of what they all believe to be the most vast copper deposit in North America, if not the world.
Only time will tell if they or anyone can do what others before them could not: turn that copper into cash.
Mark Dotson shook numerous hands and received dozens of hugs from local residents at the grand opening of Copper King Mining Corp.'s processing mill in March 2009.
The Milford man who headed Western Utah Copper Co. spent nearly half his life assembling 60,000 acres of fragmented mining claims northwest of town. Western Utah merged with Copper King a year earlier, and Dotson had big plans for the newly formed, publicly traded company.
Dotson talked about creating "cash flow, income and economic freedom" for his family, his workers, Beaver County and Milford.
"We have virtually an ocean of copper out there," he boasted at the time. "We believe we have enough resources to operate this endlessly."
The Milford Mineral Belt town covers 144 square miles and spans three mining districts. More than 20 mines dot the area, with names such as Hidden Treasure. Exchange Place, the Boston Building and the old Newhouse Hotel in downtown Salt Lake City were built with money from those mines. The area yielded its last copper around 1980.
Unlike Kennecott's Bingham Canyon mine, the copper in the Milford belt runs in veins, making it trickier to extract.
But Dotson, whose family mining roots go back to the 1850s, believed he had just the formula to make a fortune.
He borrowed heavily to build a $60 million processing plant. He wooed investors through a slick marketing campaign featuring a billboard next to iconic Capitol Records in downtown Los Angeles and actor John O'Hurley of "Seinfeld" and TV game show fame.
Dotson promised the mill would process 2,500 tons a day. He claimed the value of the copper and silver would exceed $1.2 billion within in five years, yielding revenues of $103 million annually.
Just this month, the SEC weighed in with a complaint against Dotson and his PR man, Wilford Blum, for allegedly grossly inflating those grandiose projections in press releases and public statements.
But that was long after many Milford residents bought into the hype. No one knows how many invested, but "probably more than I think," Sherwood said.
"A couple invested all they had in it," he said. "But that's small town rumor."
Gary Smith, who grew up in the town, put money into Copper King, as did some of his family members. Smith recalls the days of nice homes, manicured yards and stores on Main Street. Downtown has since dwindled to mostly empty storefronts. Houses have fallen into disrepair.
"I saw this as a real opportunity for that town to change overnight," said Smith, who lives in Centerville and visits Milford often.
But in little more than a year, Copper King Mining went bankrupt having pulled little copper from the ground.
"Their process didn't work," said Tom Munson, a lead inspector with the Utah Division of Oil, Gas and Mining. "(Dotson) thought he had the process all figured out, but he never really did. He wouldn't let anyone tell him anything. I think that was their real downfall."
Copper King's board of directors ousted Dotson just before the company filed Chapter 11 bankruptcy in May 2010.
Enter John Bryan, a wealthy financial adviser who specializes in turning insolvent businesses around and hobnobbing with the rich and famous. The Copper King board appointed Bryan to replace Dotson.
In the early ′90s,90s, he advised the Duke and Duchess of York, Prince Andrew and his then-wife, Sarah Ferguson.
"He's absolutely brill about money," the Duchess cooed, according to Kitty Kelley's "The Royals," an unauthorized biography. "Really, really brill."
That fawning apparently led to a rather public dalliance. A paparazzo snapped photos of Bryan kissing Fergie's toes while she sunbathed topless outside an Italian villa.
Bryan is now married to a Belgian model/musician and runs Copper King out of his Los Angeles office. He has obtained $15 million in financing to pay off the secured creditors and is working on a reorganization plan.
"I think this can be a big success," he said. "We believe the copper resources here are substantial."
Unlike his predecessor, though, Bryan is careful not to inflate the claim, saying it needs further study.
"We cannot have any exaggeration of any data ever again. That's an absolute must for the business going forward," he said.
Thousands of shareholders across the country will have something to say about how Copper King Mining moves forward. The committee they formed, led by San Antonio businessman Chuck Dawson, has gained rare standing in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Utah.
The group isn't enamored with Bryan and will proffer its own plan to get the mine on its feet. It lists on its website many of Bryan's glamorous but sometimes unflattering escapades.
"We haven't found any evidence he's done a damn thing," said Wright, the Florida investor who owns 12 million shares of stock that at last glance were worth less than a third of a penny per share.
Dawson and Lee Abbot, the new board chairman, fear shareholders as unsecured creditors, including some mom-and-pop Milford businesses that provided services to Copper King, will be cut out of the deal.
One of them is 82-year-old Wayne C. Wiseman who owns the Chevron station. The company owes Wiseman $82,000. He depleted his savings to cover the debt. He said he'd be happy to get half his money back, but doubts he'll see any of it.
"We want to do everything we can to see that everyone gets a fair shake out of this," Dawson said.
But, he admits, his motives aren't totally altruistic.
Dawson has led the effort to employ geologists, metallurgists and engineers to thoroughly study the land's complex mineralogy, which he said should have been done from the beginning. Like everyone else, Dawson sees the opportunity to make a lot of money.
"This is a risky venture. This is by no means a sure thing," he said. "But the potential payoff is huge."
Abbott, the former chief financial officer at Western Utah Copper who resigned just before the merger with Copper King, said a geologist told him the mine could be 10 times the size of the Kennecott's open pit Bingham Canyon Mine, which at 18.7 million tons has produced more copper than any mine in history.
"There's potentially trillions of dollars down there if this thing is mined for 300 or 400 years," he said.said. "Despite all of our studies we cannot say with a high degree of confidence that any of the deposits can be mined profitably."
Abbott's optimistic guess is that it could be operating as early as 2015.
"I'd be tickled to death," said Sherwood of that possibility.
Though it wouldn't change Milford's middle-of-nowhere locale, it could become a going-somewhere town once again.
Email: email@example.com. Twitter: dennisromboy
- LDS leaders respond to reaction over their...
- Former Utah basketball player spreads hope...
- Utah's largest oil producer lays off 80...
- LDS leaders reemphasize protection of...
- Unmasked: How the dynamic duo behind Salt...
- 'Life-changing' program for families battles...
- Watch: LDS Church news conference about...
- Rep. Chris Stewart says he's working on...
- LDS leaders reemphasize protection of... 201
- LDS leaders respond to reaction over... 64
- Lawmakers looking to pump up gas tax... 62
- Watch: LDS Church news conference about... 39
- LDS statement could move Utah... 31
- Concealed permit holder stopped armed... 25
- Business community supports tax... 22
- Former Utah basketball player spreads... 22