Challenging Issues, Keeping the Faith: Challenging Issues, Keeping the Faith: The difference between Old and New World archaeology
Before I begin sharing some of the interesting New World evidences that are consistent with an ancient Book of Mormon, there is one more topic to discuss regarding the way some critics approach Book of Mormon archaeology.
Some critics like to compare the lack of archaeological support for the Book of Mormon with the supposedly voluminous archaeological support for the Bible. As Dr. William Hamblin has pointed out, however, there is a drastic difference between the Old and New Worlds when it comes to epigraphic (written) data, the continuity of culture and toponyms (place names). While the arid environment of biblical archaeology is conducive to preserving archaeological artifacts, the hot, humid Mesoamerican climate is detrimental to the preservation of most artifacts such as wood, bone, metal and clothing.
There’s also a big difference between the general states of New and Old World archaeology. Many more decades, resources and experts have been devoted to “biblical archaeology” than to Mesoamerican archaeology. In 1980, for instance, one New World scholar claimed that less than 1 percent of known ancient American sites had been excavated (cited in "The Firm Foundation of Mormonism," 103).
Thirty years later, it doesn’t appear that things have improved. Doctoral candidate Mark A. Wright tells of a recent conversation with Dr. George Stuart, who up until his recent emeritus status was National Geographic’s resident Maya archaeologist. Stuart complained that of the 6,000 known ancient Mayan sites, only 1 percent of them had been excavated. The 1 percent to be excavated have only been about 5-10 percent uncovered. Adding salt to the wound is the fact that many ancient American sites are looted before archaeologists can fully examine them.
As noted last week, most ancient societies wrote on perishable materials. Even in the Old World, where we have rare exceptions of texts written on metal, stone or clay, most other documents have vanished. Nearly all surviving ancient Greek and Roman books, for instance, are actually copies of copies from the eighth century or later. The disappearance of ancient texts is the norm, not an aberration. Thanks to unique ecological conditions conducive to preservation, however, several thousand texts and contemporary inscriptions from biblical lands have survived to modern times.
These surviving texts are significant tools in helping archaeologists locate ancient biblical cities. Some ancient documents even give detailed lists of distances between cities. Knowing the exact location of one city helps biblical archaeologists locate other cities, simply by calculating the distances.
Even with such Old World advantages, however, only slightly more than half of all place names mentioned in the Bible have been located and positively identified. Most of these identifications are based on toponym preservation. For biblical locations with no preserved toponym, only about 7 to 8 percent of them have been identified to a degree of certainty, and about another 7 to 8 percent of them have been identified with some degree of conjectural certainty. The identification of those locations without place names could not have been made were it not for the identification of locations with preserved toponyms. If few or no biblical toponyms survived, the identification of biblical locations would be largely speculative.
When we turn to the New World, we find that many toponyms disappeared from one era to the next. Archaeologists simply don’t know the original names for all ancient American cities. With such considerations, how could we ever hope to provide translated English names for those cities — such as names provided in the Book of Mormon?
- Letters to family show Steven Powell still...
- Sister Frances J. Monson's legacy of love...
- Live streaming: Frances J. Monson funeral
- Defending the Faith: A case for the...
- 'Tattooed Mormon' Al Fox shares her...
- USA Today takes note of LDS sister missionaries
- Boy Scouts of America to make membership...
- 'Hollywood goes to Mormon country': BYU...
- 'Tattooed Mormon' Al Fox shares her... 39
- Defending the Faith: A case for the... 32
- Muslim leaders in U.S. facing... 25
- 'We're here to serve all boys,' Utah... 23
- Secretary of State John Kerry says... 23
- Wright Words: Oklahoma tornado provides... 23
- Supreme Court to weigh in on... 17
- Letters to family show Steven Powell... 16