Prosecutors' witnesses all OK'd for Smart case

Published: Monday, Nov. 16, 2009 9:49 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

Prosecutors will be allowed to use all of their intended witnesses in the upcoming competency hearing of accused Elizabeth Smart kidnapper Brian David Mitchell, including their expert witness, Dr. Michael Welner.

On Monday, U.S. Magistrate Dale Kimball denied several motions by Mitchell aimed at preventing the testimonies of Welner, all lay witnesses, Richard Forbes, Daniel Peterson and the writings of Ervil LeBaron to be introduced during Mitchell's upcoming competency hearing in federal court.

In addition, Kimball denied a motion to have the Nov. 30 hearing continued to a later date.

With the exception of Smart, who already delivered her testimony in October, and growing speculation that co-defendant Wanda Barzee will take the stand against her estranged husband, Welner is expected to be the government's key witness during the competency hearing.

Welner, a renowned forensic psychiatrist from New York City, has prepared a 206-page report on Mitchell in which he concludes Mitchell is competent to stand trial. In his report, Welner lists 161 sources of information, according to court records.

Defense attorneys argued Welner's methodology was flawed and his conclusions weren't supported by his findings. But Kimball in his ruling said Welner's testimony "is reliable expert opinion."

Story continues below

As for lay witnesses, Kimball noted the government's notion that Mitchell was malingering, or faking his illness, to avoid prosecution could not be completely discounted.

"It cannot be disputed, however, that there is an issue in this case as to whether (Mitchell) is malingering. As a result, the court concludes that lay witness testimony is relevant," Kimball said in his ruling.

LeBaron, the head of a polygamous cult believed to be responsible for murders in Utah and several other states, was never found incompetent to stand trial.

Forbes is a former head investigator for the Salt Lake County Attorney's Office and helped lead the murder investigation and subsequent conviction of LeBaron.

Peterson, a professor of Islamic Studies, is expected to testify about Judeo-Christian scripture.

Forbes is expected to testify that Mitchell's book, "The Book of Immanuel David Isaiah," is similar to LeBaron's "The Book of the New Covenant." His testimony, combined with Peterson's, will show that Mitchell's religious beliefs are grandiose but not delusional, according to prosecutors.

In his ruling, Kimball said the defense could raise objections on individual points during cross-examination.

e-mail: preavy@desnews.com

Recent comments

Not to mention the report "is the product of reliable principles and...

Commenting | Nov. 20, 2009 at 2:15 p.m.

About time. Now find him guilty as charged & throw him in prison...

Lacee | Nov. 17, 2009 at 2:25 a.m.

Related content
previousnext

Latest comments

To: 'New Yorker' You blow your own credibility when you speak like that.

For RSL, being late worked

No, the Seahawks play at the Vikings on sunday. The game is still at Qwest...

I love you grandpa.

Beckham says he'll be ready

I like Donovan, class act he is. But my RSL will beat them! Good, I'm glad...

Editorial: Obama in China

I wouldn't matter if Huntsman was to work miracles with China and the US in...

Drs. have always been key in addressing medical costs. It would've been nice...

How did I forget about the first Utah win???? My bad. 2-2 Ute Fans are...

Letters: Bill curbs right to choose

I disagree with the wars in both Iraq and Afghanistan, therefore I have a...

EXTREMELY OVERRATED!

Broncos make Aggies pay

The Aggies are definitely on the right track now, and expect them to be as...

Advertisements