Jackpot: Lawyers earn fees from law they wrote

Published: Sunday, Nov. 15, 2009 1:36 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Every lawsuit filed or even threatened under a California law aimed at electing more minorities to local offices — and all of the roughly $4.3 million from settlements so far — can be traced to just two people: a pair of attorneys who worked together writing the statute, The Associated Press has found.

The law makes it easier for lawyers to sue and win financial judgments in cases arising from claims that minorities effectively were shut out of local elections, while shielding attorneys from liability if the claims are tossed out.

The law was drafted mainly by Seattle law professor Joaquin Avila, with advice from lawyers including Robert Rubin, legal director for the Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area. Avila, Rubin's committee and lawyers working with them have collected or billed local governments about $4.3 million in three cases that settled, and could reap more from two pending lawsuits.

That's only a fraction of what might come. Dozens of cities and school boards have been warned they could be sued under the 2002 California Voting Rights Act.

All the cases have been initiated by Rubin's committee or Avila, who also is a member of the lawyers' group, according to an Associated Press review of legal documents, correspondence and legislative records, and interviews with lawyers, school and government officials, current and former legislators and voting-rights experts.

Story continues below

There is nothing illegal about the lawyers profiting from a law they authored and state lawmakers approved. But it is unusual that after seven years all legal efforts are so narrowly focused, especially since Avila told lawmakers when he testified for the bill in 2002 that he expected other attorneys would take on cases because of favorable incentives written into the measure.

Avila said the complexity of the litigation and the fact few attorneys are experts in voting rights have limited the number involved so far.

"I anticipate there will be more cases filed by other parties," he said.

Avila and Rubin say their roles in crafting the law shouldn't overshadow its importance and the need to use lawsuits and threats to end years of injustice at the polls. Those they target dispute the need for the law. The number of minority officeholders was climbing even before it was enacted, and they claim the lawyers are using the statute to shake down local governments.

"It's a money grab," charged John Stafford, superintendent of the Madera Unified School District that was slapped with a $1.2 million attorneys' bill even though it never contested a lawsuit.

Recent comments

By minorities I assume they are talking about illegal alien...

Minorities or? | Nov. 16, 2009 at 6:10 a.m.

Lawyers are Officers of the Court. Now isn't that a scary thought?...

Officers of the Court | Nov. 15, 2009 at 3:45 p.m.

This smacks of conflict of interest and corruption. The fox is in the...

Sick and Wrong | Nov. 15, 2009 at 2:58 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

I don't believe this is the shroud that Jesus was wrapped in. I think there...

Palin plans tour stop in Utah

I find it hard to trust someone who doesn't even know the correct...

This family did not come illegal and did not do anything illegal. They...

Pound the rock with the combo of Unga, Tonga, Karriya and JJ. Once their...

I am a businessman in China and I agree 100% with what Ambassador Huntsman...

Boozer looking like 'the old Booz'

Boozer has said in the past or the future for that matter. Talk is just part...

Hall not distracted by wins record

So winning a bowl game isnt a big win? how about beating Oklahoma on a...

Juan Diego wins 3A title

looks like the hurricane curse continues.....this may have been their closet...

Juan Diego wins 3A title

I think it's safe to say that 99.9 percent of high school football fans are...

Oh yes! Put me down as another ecstatic Democrat just hoping, praying, and...

Advertisements