Google makes concessions on digital book deal

Published: Saturday, Nov. 14, 2009 9:00 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

SAN FRANCISCO — Internet search leader Google will ease its control over millions of copyright-protected books earmarked for its digital library if a court approves a revised lawsuit settlement that addresses objections of antitrust regulators.

The offer comes two months after the U.S. Justice Department balked at Google's original agreement with authors and publishers, warning the arrangement could do more harm than good in the emerging market for electronic books.

Google Inc. is hoping to keep the deal alive with a series of new provisions. Among other things, the modified agreement provides more flexibility to offer discounts on electronic books and promises to make it easier for others to resell access to a digital index of books covered in the settlement.

Copyright holders also would have to give more explicit permission to sell digital book copies if another version is being sold anywhere else in the world.

The concessions filed late Friday in New York federal court are just the latest twist in a class-action lawsuit filed against Google four years ago by groups representing the interests of U.S. authors and publishers. The suit alleged Google's ambition to make digital copies of all the books in the world trampled their intellectual rights.

Story continues below

Google negotiated a $125 million truce nearly 13 months ago only to be attacked by a brigade of critics who protested to U.S. District Judge Denny Chin, who must approve the agreement before it takes effect. The financial terms of the settlement remain intact, including a promise to give 63 percent of all sales proceeds to participating authors and publishers.

Among other complaints, the opposition said the plan would put Google in charge of a literary cartel that could illegally rig the prices of electronic books — a format that is expected to become increasingly popular.

In echoing some of those concerns, the Justice Department advised Chin that the original settlement probably would break laws set up to preserve competition and protect copyright holders, even if they can't be located.

The concessions didn't go far enough to satisfy one of the most strident opponents, Open Book Alliance, a group that includes Google rivals Microsoft Corp., Yahoo Inc. and Amazon.com Inc.

"Our initial review of the new proposal tells us that Google and its partners are performing a sleight of hand," said Peter Brantley, the Open Book Alliance's co-chairman. "Fundamentally, this settlement remains a set-piece designed to serve the private commercial interests of Google and its partners."

Recent comments

@Ridiculous, if you had read the article to the end, you would have...

Zadruga Guy | Nov. 15, 2009 at 10:51 a.m.

First, if they can't find an author... they keep the money? Our...

Ridiculous | Nov. 14, 2009 at 9:27 a.m.

Image
Carlos Osorio, Associated Press

A scanner passes over a book at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, Mich., where one of hundreds of librarians from all over the world was helping Google Inc.'s Book Search create digital versions of all the estimated 50 million to 100 million books in the world.

previousnext

Latest comments

how cool is that...good for you...good for Xango...good for all :} kj brown CA

Learn how to fill out a report, Chaffetz and friends.

Yes, Sodom and Gomorrah both hate America.

Let's see, we have had slaveholders, old soldiers, a haberdasher, a guy in a...

Lucky! In-N-Out is the best! Grew up loving them and am thousands of miles...

All this type "rivalry" type stuff is soooo IMMATURE! Grow up and act like...

'The Blind Side' akin to 'comfort food'

The book really puts the BYU high school credit program in a bad light.......

Kick their smurf bottoms

typcial police work, they assume a stereotype and they stop investigating

It seems that something that affects all of the American people should be a...

Advertisements