Fear of government hinders health-care reform

Published: Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2009 12:09 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

What if all the hysteria over health-care reform isn't about health care at all? What if it's more a deep-seated fear of government interference in our lives?

It's the $64,000 question, isn't it?

So that you know where I'm coming from, I do not have an inherent mistrust of government. I do not buy into the "death panels" frenzy, nor do I think that access to health care can be strictly left to the private sector.

But listening to Mike Leavitt speak last week gave me new insight into the political realities of reform and the visceral, gut reaction many Americans have to the whole affair.

Leavitt, former secretary of Health and Human Services, addressing the National Conference of Editorial Writers, spoke about his great optimism when he became the head of the agency under former President George W. Bush. As such, Leavitt had his hands on the steering wheel of the nation's largest health-care programs. He had designs on making the systems more efficient and cost-effective and improving the quality of care.

The problem was, 535 other people — members of Congress — also had their hands on the wheel, which made meaningful change next to impossible.

Story continues below

Take the agency's brief flirtation with a trial competitive bidding process on 10 durable medical goods in 10 cities. The demonstration project revealed huge savings could be achieved through this process, an average savings of 26 percent on the 10 items, with the cost savings as great as 43 percent on specific items.

But in a competitive bidding process, low bidders who meet the specifications win the contracts. The rest go away empty-handed. So they start complaining to their congressional representatives. And their industry representatives start pressuring members of Congress to pull the plug on the pilot project, which they did.

"I was, essentially, politically stoned," Leavitt said.

Never mind the folks who pay the tab to keep the government afloat and who would have appreciated the substantial savings the program could have achieved.

Leavitt, who was elected Utah governor three times, said he understands why so many Americans are wary of the health-care proposals coming down the pike. They don't like change in general, and they cannot see how they will benefit from these particular changes. And they don't understand how the government will pay for it.

Recent comments

If they present information from outside the proffered alternatives,...

Anonymous | Oct. 22, 2009 at 5:24 a.m.

"What if all the hysteria over health-care reform isn't about health...

Anonymous | Sept. 30, 2009 at 6:54 p.m.

Tyranny is when when the people fear the government.

Freedom is...

Fear and Government | Sept. 30, 2009 at 1:19 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Aggies shoot past Cougars

Good win Aggies, but really, can we stop with the "We are so great (at home)"...

Ha ha,

Aggies shoot past Cougars

Allow me to clear up why the Ags and Cougs played on a nuetral court last...

Gay marriage is not a threat to "traditional" marriage. The LGBT community...

All the BYU fans come to rally around their team, and the best they can come...

Really? No setter on first team allstate? Ashley played middle at this year...

It is very clear who is the best team in the MWC. Cougar fans can look to...

No, a heterosexual male can only marry the person they choose if that person...

Matthews strength is his ability to stay between him and the defender. He is...

Letters: Cave was a life-saver

Thank you for sharing in the wake of tragedy.

Advertisements