Women lose court bid to ski jump in Vancouver

Published: Friday, July 10, 2009 4:02 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

VANCOUVER, British Columbia — A group of women ski jumpers lost its case to be part of the 2010 Winter Olympics.

The British Columbia Supreme Court said Friday it doesn't have the authority to force the International Olympic Committee to put the sport on the program.

Fifteen former and current female ski jumpers went to court in April, contending their exclusion from the Vancouver Games violated the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

The IOC maintains female ski jumpers are prevented from competing at the games because they fail to meet Olympic criteria, not because of gender discrimination.

The women wanted a court declaration ordering the Vancouver organizing committee to either hold women's ski jumping in 2010 or cancel all ski jumping events.

"We believe we had a fair hearing," said Ross Clark, the women's lawyer. "We accept the judge's ruling, but we also need time to consider whether we will appeal."

Justice Lauri Ann Fenlon expressed sympathy for the women but ruled the IOC is not governed by the Charter, and the organization does not fall under the court's jurisdiction.

Story continues below

"The IOC made a decision that discriminates against the plaintiffs," Fenlon wrote in her 42-page decision. "Only the IOC can alleviate that discrimination by including an Olympic ski jumping event for women in the 2010 Games.

"There will be little solace to the plaintiffs in my finding that they have been discriminated against; there is no remedy available to them in this court."

The IOC said it was pleased the games can proceed as planned but objected to the court's comment that it acted with bias.

"Our decision was based on technical issues, without regard to gender," the IOC said in a statement.

Katie Willis, one of the women named as a plaintiff, said she will probably quit ski jumping.

"All of my dreams since I was 8 years old, to go to the Olympics," she told The Canadian Press by phone from Calgary, Alberta. "All these little girls coming up, a lot of their dreams are crashing. There isn't the 2010 Games to shoot for anymore."

Willis took little comfort in the judge saying the women were discriminated against.

"It is a moral victory because she noted it was discrimination and it was the IOC that is discriminating against us," she said. "But it is hollow because she says she can't do anything because it's not the Vancouver Olympic committee."

John Furlong, chief executive of the Vancouver organizers, said his group will continue to plan for the men's ski jump. He called the issue a "difficult and challenging process for all involved."

"We appreciate Justice Fenlon's careful consideration of the very complex issues," he said.

One of the legal points at issue was whether the Charter applies to the Vancouver committee. Fenlon said the committee was not in breach of the Charter.

"VANOC has no power either to order the inclusion of women's ski jumping in the Olympic program or to order the removal of men's ski jumping from the 2010 Games," she wrote. "In other words, VANOC is not under a duty to distribute equally what is has no power to provide."

Deedee Corradini, president of Women Ski Jumping-USA, promised to keep fighting for her sport.

"We won't give up until women's ski jumping is in the Olympics," she said. "But it's unfortunate this legal effort failed and they won't be in 2010."

Recent comments

Let them jump, and watch them soar.

Please | July 10, 2009 at 6:47 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Broncos make Aggies pay

These message boards are for trading insults.....so if you don't want to be...

Boys basketball rankings

Did JD Books change his name to Porkins? Easy there fella

BYU has slim shot at BCS

RE: BYU accounting grad. Most employers could give a hoot about your...

Best of luck to this young man. I do hope they get him out soon!

SUU falls to Tennessee Tech

This team plays with very little heart at times. They had better step it up...

Bill Clinton was the unknown man on the grassy knoll.

Utahn is starving herself for Kenya

Like in all honesty her starving herself is going to get govt officials in a...

Where do I need to go to sign this petition. It is long overdue.

I understand her desire to spread the word and make a difference, but I...

Preps of the week

Reading is fundamental. Selected by ESPN as top player in state and signed...

Advertisements