Tramel: Utah gets pity party on Capitol Hill

Published: Wednesday, July 8, 2009 11:29 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

Sometimes, you don't know who your friends are.

In the last five years, four mid-major college football teams, squadrons on the outside of college football's cartel, have played in Bowl Championship Series bowls. Utah in the 2009 Sugar and 2005 Fiesta. Hawaii in the 2008 Sugar. Boise State in the 2007 Fiesta.

In the 54 seasons before 2004, four mid-majors made BCS bowls or the high-paying, New Year's Day bowls that eventually formed the BCS: Air Force in the 1959 Cotton and 1971 Sugar, Wyoming in the 1968 Sugar and Louisville in the 1991 Fiesta.

So tell me again why on Tuesday a Mountain West Conference lawyer sat on Capitol Hill and did what so many lawyers before him have done. Asked Congress to investigate what he believes is an antitrust violation.

Never mind that Congress couldn't get to the bottom of a purse snatching on Mayberry's Main Street.

Why would the Mountain West try to take down the BCS? The BCS has been good to the Mountain West and the Western Athletic Conference. The BCS is the friend of the Utahs and Brigham Youngs and Fresno States.

Story continues below

The BCS did more in half a decade for the profile and standing of the mid-majors than any single coach, player, school or system did in the half century before, with the exception of BYU coaching legend LaVell Edwards.

The testimony Tuesday in Washington was all show. Sen. Herb Kohl (D-Wis.) gaveled the Senate Judiciary subcommittee to order but quickly left. Sen. Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.) stayed a couple of minutes. That left only one senator, Utah Republican Orrin Hatch, to hear witnesses.

A lawyer for each side debated whether the BCS breaks the Sherman Antitrust Act, then school leaders for each side, Nebraska chancellor Harvey Perlman and Utah president Michael Young, offered their takes.

When the U.S. House staged a similar hearing in May, three committee members appeared. We all have asked the question doesn't Congress have better things to do? The answer obviously is yes, judging by the attendance at the subcommittee hearings.

This was a Utah pity party, nothing more. I'm a longtime supporter of the Mountain West Conference. I advocate an automatic BCS berth for the Mountain West, and I annually rip the NCAA basketball committee for short-changing the mid-majors.

I'm not even anti-playoff, so long as it's an 11-team playoff that includes all the conference champions. But Congress can't fix anything, and the Mountain West has limited credibility in this case.

Recent comments

1- He failed to mention BYU in the Cotton Bowl January 1, 1997

2-...

facts and logic | July 9, 2009 at 12:42 a.m.

The problem with the reasoning that only a few mid majors have made...

Starting Rank | July 9, 2009 at 12:25 a.m.

First of all the fact that he is calling the "rest of the football...

fan | July 8, 2009 at 8:32 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Otters don't eat much trout - they stick to slower moving fish. They also eat...

ive heard good reviews of this movie and bad ones guess ill just have to find...

BYU's old uniforms?

Sounds good to me. Only do it for the bowl game where National...

Rivalry Week is highly profane

I'm a BYU Fan and I am pretty embarassed by this photo. I guess this is how...

He was probably rushing to a $3 toaster a Target.

I praise the decision to close the cave. One life is to many and it will save...

Finally an excellent idea borne out of tragedy. Kudos to the people that...

Rivalry Week is highly profane

I can't wait to read the excuses the Bougars have after tomorrow's game. I'm...

Logan aims for impact on Wynn

Hey Utah Fans: I am still trying to get over how you all showed us what it...

Tiger you better call me. Sounds like you better take care of the driving on...

Advertisements