Bankruptcies low in states that don't seize wages

Published: Sunday, July 5, 2009 6:09 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

States that allow debt collectors to seize consumers' wages have sharply higher bankruptcy rates than neighboring states that prohibit or strictly limit the practice, an Associated Press analysis has found.

This link highlights a dilemma for credit-card companies and other debt chasers: By going after wages — an increasingly popular maneuver since the recession began, lawyers say — they risk pushing consumers into bankruptcy court, where judges can reduce or wipe away all sorts of financial obligations.

The apparent relationship between so-called garnishment laws and states' bankruptcy rates also bolsters the arguments of consumer advocates, who have long said that intercepting someone's wages to pay their debts only increases their financial vulnerability.

After gathering millions of bankruptcy records from 2006 until now, the AP plotted the number of filings for each U.S. county in its Economic Stress Map — a geographic, chronological and visual depiction of economic misery based on unemployment, foreclosure and bankruptcy data.

Story continues below

While bankruptcy rates vary for many reasons, the five states that prohibit or strongly limit wage seizures — North Carolina, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Florida and Texas — all have drastically lower rates than their neighbors, with particularly striking differences along borders, where economic conditions are similar but bankruptcy rates are not.

South Carolina's bankruptcy rate is almost one-quarter that of Georgia's; Pennsylvania has half the rate of Ohio; North Carolina has about one-third the rate of Tennessee; Texas has a smaller rate than all its neighbors; and Florida has just about half the rates of Georgia and Alabama.

The Carolinas, Pennsylvania and Texas prohibit wage garnishment, except in special circumstances such as unpaid taxes or child support. Florida prohibits garnishing wages from the head of a household.

The nationwide bankruptcy rate is 42 percent higher than the rate in those five states.

Bankruptcy filings have been steadily rising since the end of 2005, when a change in federal law sent filing rates plummeting. The number of filings in May were 35 percent higher than a year earlier, and more than 1.2 million cases have been filed in the past 12 months.

Debts are usually delinquent for several months before companies target consumers for recovery. Creditors must get court approval to seize a person's wages or other assets. Federal law and state laws restrict how much can be taken — typically 25 percent of "disposable" income, or income after taxes and other legally required deductions.

Recent comments

The financial services industry is going to kill itself by pushing...

Anonymous | July 6, 2009 at 7:47 a.m.

It's a crisis, we obviously need Gov funded bankruptcy protection...

Dave | July 6, 2009 at 7:43 a.m.

"States that allow debt collectors to seize consumers' wages have...

anonymous | July 5, 2009 at 10:51 p.m.

Image
Butch Dill, Associated Press

In this July 1 photo, Cheryl Greer poses outside her home in Cullman, Ala. Under state wage garnishment law, Greer's employer held back money from her paycheck to pay debt. Greer filed for bankruptcy protection in May.

previousnext

Latest comments

Compliments to the governor on his staffing decisions here.

BYU remembers Black 14 game

Kittens, ...enjoy the new mexico bowl...hahaha!! Go Utes!!!!!!!!!!

No jail in book scheme

I remember when this first came to light. It was appalling someone would...

Poll Results | 10:27 p.m., You're playing fast and loose with the numbers...

Parry's Power Guide

I think James Edward has kicked Parry's butt about every year. Perhaps go...

No jail in book scheme

What a Neanderthal.

No jail in book scheme

Don't blame the judge, I'm sure he passed down what the law allows him to....

Right on Joe M about the government...dems and repubs...but I think a lot of...

I heard from a very, very successful coach that he of course knew who his...

No, I want the average every day person that has hurt in life, that has life...

Advertisements
Advertisement