Machines to do court reporting

Stenographers will be released from jobs June 30 as a part of cost-cutting

Published: Monday, June 22, 2009 1:21 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

PROVO — There's no sound as Jeff Eaton's fingers fly over the small keyboard, documenting every "Yes, your honor," "Could you please describe that to the jury," and "The record will reflect."

But come June 30, Eaton's fingers will take a rest as he and his colleagues are released from their state jobs as court stenographers — the keepers of the record.

It was a decision mandated by the Legislature as the state faced growing expenses and dwindling budgets.

Initially the courts were asked to slice off $4.5 million, said Daniel Becker, who heads the Administrative Office of the Courts. But the final required cut was larger: just over $5.5 million, he said.

Of that amount, $3.8 million is from personnel — 18 certified court reporters, 18 clerks, 11 administrative level jobs, 11.5 jobs from juvenile/probation services, four custodians and one law clerk.

"With respect to the court reporters, it was really based on the fact that there is another way of getting the work done that costs considerably less," Becker said. "And (we are) already doing that other kind of work."

By using courtrooms' digital recording systems rather than fast-fingered typists, Becker said, the state will save about $1.15 million a year.

But Eaton, supervising reporter in 4th District Court, and his colleagues question that figure.

Story continues below

"I understand the reasons for cutting back the budget," Eaton said. "(But) the public needs to know … if there is being represented there is savings, exactly what that savings is."

Old vs. new

Before June 30, 17 official court reporters meticulously documented every word of various hearings, occasionally asking for clarification of mumbled words or phrases. After the hearing, they typed up a verbatim record.

Eaton uses five backup systems including hard drives, external drives and a real-time feed to his computer.

The court reporters were salaried, and their transcript fees — money from the attorneys buying their record at $3.50 a page — all went into a state fund.

Court stenographers could draw from that fund to pay for training or new equipment, Eaton said.

But after June 30, the record will be digitally gathered by court microphones only.

When attorneys need a transcript, the court will turn to a list of certified reporters, or employees of certified reporters, who will listen to the tape, then type every word.

But unlike Eaton, they can't ask for clarification. And there are no backup systems for a digital glitch.

Court administrators insist it won't be a huge change because audio systems have already been used in Utah courts since the mid-'90s.

Recent comments

I have read many of the comments and I must say, I think the price to...

Steno Student | Aug. 27, 2009 at 7:36 p.m.

okay, let me tell you what happens with video/audio recordings in a...

TAOFAFT | July 31, 2009 at 7:50 p.m.

First, let me just say...WOW. I agree that there seems to be a lot...

Alikrorp225 | July 29, 2009 at 10:28 p.m.

Image

Jodi Sudweeks types a verbatim record of a hearing under Judge Deno Himonas at the 3rd District Court on Friday.

previousnext

Latest comments

Is this just one more sign of an ever increasing police state? Every...

Corroon is a decent common sense politician... however this poll will really...

17 year old, driving, most likely, under the influence, illegal drugs,...

Michael R. Ash states: "That Joseph used a seer stone in a hat to translate...

I'm very happy with your articles Mr. Ash! Thank you & please keep them...

The First few Decisions Herbert made, and things he said proved he was not...

Man dies in dirt bike crash

I was just thinking of his goofy antics at the MTC yesterday. I will miss him.

A deficit commission?

If I want to reduce my debt then I cut up my credit cards and reduce my...

Editorial: East, West and religion

Spell check. If you can't even spell it correctly, it's pretty certain you...

Larry, the please explain why marriage is synonymous with churches. Where do...

Advertisements