Drug testing for welfare recipients?

Published: Wednesday, June 17, 2009 7:10 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

Utahns on state and federal assistance programs may find themselves subject to random drug testing.

That proposal was aired Wednesday afternoon before the Workforce Services and Community and Economic Development Interim Committee. The committee took no action, but revealed clearly the notion is anything but cut and dried.

Sen. Dennis Stowell, R-Parowan, said one of his constituents came to him concerned that it is not fair that those on government assistance are not subject to the same substance abuse testing practices and consequences for those who are employed. In so many words, Stowell asked, why can't someone on welfare lose benefits for the same thing?

First of all, the welfare system implied by the question hasn't existed for 13 years, said Sen. Luz Robles, D-Salt Lake, whose constituency includes many families who receive temporary government support and cash payments. They, like anyone who receives assistance nationwide, are on a lifetime maximum cash-assistance limit of five years.

Story continues below

Plus, the idea of adding another barrier to people who are "desperately trying to get back on their feet with help from these programs" defies societal, economic and even common sense, particularly given the fact that lawmakers have just imposed deep budget cuts on substance abuse treatment and prevention programs, Robles said.

Robles and other committee members agreed that taking up the proposal in any serious, deliberate way first requires them to be clear on intent and what good it would do.

It's already doing some good if it initiates the long-avoided but much-needed discussion among lawmakers to honestly assess the role and relationship state and federal government in dealing with poverty, said Sen. Mark Madsen, R-Lehi. He called the implications of dealing with the issue much more far-reaching than drug testing itself.

Rep. Steve Mascaro, R-West Jordan, endorsed discussing the measure further but advised fellow lawmakers that the argument for imposing a behavioral expectations of the employer/employee relationship on a segment of the population in the margins of society — especially when random testing is being viewed by many courts across the country as a violation of the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution — "has a long way to go to persuade me."

According to Community Action Partnership Utah, a network of advocates who coordinate services and help people in poverty, there are about 6,500 Utahns who receive cash assistance through the Temporary Assistance for Need Families federal block grant, or the Family Employment Program, as it is now called in Utah. A demographic profile of the recipients by CAPU shows that 94 percent are single women, 74 percent are white and more than 60 percent have children. They each receive $498 a month.

Melissa Smith, a government policy analyst for CAPU, said the those receiving assistance have no greater substance abuse problems than the 4.9 percent rate among Utah's general population. No state has imposed random drug testing on this group, according to Smith and the state Department of Workforce Services, which oversees the program for Utah.

E-MAIL: jthalman@desnews.com

Recent comments

I think that New York State should do the drug and alcohol testing...

Jack | June 20, 2009 at 10:01 p.m.

If it wasn't for the farmers you all would not have much to eat now...

Putter | June 19, 2009 at 8:04 a.m.

Oh yeah, farmers getting subsidies is JUST like welfare. Just don't...

Anonymous | June 19, 2009 at 12:20 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Letters: Let others live own lives

I'm the guy who wrote at 12:31, and I've been rereading my post and trying to...

Calling on ALL Cougar Alumni: Today the A.D. at Boise State put out a...

Heroes' actions stemmed Army loss

Back in the 19th century, someone (I think it was a NYC fire chief) said that...

So you are against mandatory car insurance too? You don't want all those...

This debate on whether or not The Flyers can beat the 5A schools is...

Hall, Cougars crush Cowboys

BYU should have lost this game on purpose and they should lose all the rest...

5A football: Alta reaches semis

News to you........You can't stop our passing game! If we jump on you early,...

Utes pound winless Lobos

Yea, Moose...Boise State won their game and they are going to need help from...

Anyone know how many penalties were called? Had to be about 30.

Hall, Cougars crush Cowboys

"Jake Locker of UW almost singlehandedly beat BYU last year w his...

Advertisements
Advertisement