Stop crying about BYU's 'advantage'

Published: Saturday, June 13, 2009 11:52 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

Baird continued, saying "when they return from serving their mission, they are older, and I promise you kids mature a lot from 18 to 22." An additional shot: "What other school in the country — or religion for that matter — has church missions that take place during a player's college career? Then there would be no need for the mission exception at all. Then everyone would be playing by the same set of rules. Now I realize that other colleges that sign LDS players also benefit from this rule, but my point is any rule shouldn't give anyone an advantage, and this one does."

Oh, waaaah!

BYU has more turnover than any other school, due to missions. And while players may come back bigger and stronger — and almost everyone comes back more mature — they also come back fatter and slower.

If having 24-year-old players is such an advantage, how come USC doesn't have 20 of them? Don't tell me it's because LDS players wouldn't want to go there.

Pete Carroll would rather have someone who runs a 4.3 than a mature guy who runs a 4.7, any day.

An all-time truism is that every school goes to its strength. Some use academics, some use location, others use reputation. Notre Dame uses tradition and religion to recruit. Arizona reportedly used cheerleaders in a recruiting brochure, claiming it had the prettiest in the country.

For anyone to intimate the best LDS players go to BYU because they feel pressured is oversimplifying. If BYU football stunk, hardly any good players would show up. As it is, some heralded LDS players didn't go to BYU. Haloti Ngata (Oregon), Manti Te'o (Notre Dame) and Stanley Havili (USC) said no. Ben Olson went to BYU, served a mission and transferred to UCLA.

Story continues below

BYU doesn't have a guarantee on anyone. But the fact it has an edge with LDS players only balances the fact it must recruit around missions and the nation's most rigid honor code.

Name another school that could and would render a player ineligible for drinking coffee.

If LDS kids are inclined to go to BYU, that's natural. Florida kids want to play at Florida, Texas kids in Texas. Party kids want to go to Wisconsin. Military kids want to go to Navy or Air Force.

Don't like playing against married, mature players?

Go get your own.

Otherwise, show up and play with what you can get.

BYU has been doing it for years.

E-MAIL: rock@desnews.com

Recent comments

It's amazing that people have the perception BYU has an advantage by...

DL Porter | June 20, 2009 at 11:10 a.m.

It is great to get committments of best recruits. It is another...

A "Blue" Bird in the Hand | June 19, 2009 at 6:51 p.m.

He wasn't sticking up for byu. He only hates the pub that the SEC...

re: 9:14 | June 19, 2009 at 9:06 a.m.

Image

Prized prep football recruits Zac Stout, left, Ross Apo and Jake Heaps will sign letters to attend BYU next year.

previousnext

Latest comments

BYU eager for crack at Oregon State

Keep it clean or go join the Crimson Line!

BCS reform still needed

I think that the TCU and Boise State teams should agree to not play the game....

BYU eager for crack at Oregon State

No, Maxie will not make it. He'll be QBing for Utah since their QB couldn't...

I would hate it if the Jazz end up having a record that warrants only one...

Fewer bees mean fewer plants get pollinated which means less food. What do...

I ask with sincerity, who of you 59 commenting have read Palin's book? Write...

A woman shouldn't have an abortion, because of the right's of the child -...

TCU versus BSU unpopular

BYU Fan & BCS Cowards, I agree, they should withdraw to make a point but...

Everybody whines every time we get the invite to the Vegas Bowl, why? Here is...

Utahn aiding poor

Louis has inspired me to be passionately involved with the poor both with my...

Advertisements