Stop crying about BYU's 'advantage'

Published: Saturday, June 13, 2009 11:52 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

Now that top-rated quarterback Jake Heaps has verbally committed to play football at BYU, it stands to reason some people would whine about it.

It's all unfair, you know. Heaps is LDS, and those Mormon kids ALWAYS go to BYU. The church hits 'em with the guilt trip, and there they go, marching in lock step, down to Provo. Then they complete those two-year missions, and that helps the Cougars even more. Their players come back bigger, stronger and more mature.

It's not fair.

I have only one thing to say to those who feel that way: Grow up.

Everyone uses their recruiting advantages.

The pros and cons BYU encounters in football balance out. Which is why the program is able to compete on an upper-division level in the first place.

The issue came to light nine days ago, when Heaps called a press conference in downtown Salt Lake City to announce he was going to BYU. At the same time, two other highly regarded LDS players said they would follow.

This brought the usual groans from opposing fan bases. Among the most vocal critics was former Washington assistant coach Dick Baird, who took on the issue of BYU and recruiting in a column for the Washington Huskies' fan Web site Dawgman.com.

Story continues below

Baird resurrected an old complaint, intimating that BYU bends the recruiting rules by contacting players through ecclesiastical authorities. You know the gripe: coach Bronco Mendenhall can't talk to a player as early as he wants, or as many times as he wants, but the bishop sure can.

"Somehow, BYU has been able to communicate almost at will with him and they have done so through the church," he wrote. "The LDS Church is one of the fastest-growing churches in the country, and they are organized all the way down to the ward level. It is very difficult to beat them on a Mormon kid, because they pull out all stops to keep their young in the fold."

Yet if you believe Heaps, he said he felt no religious pressure whatsoever to attend BYU. Either way, Baird went on to say the NCAA's deferred eligibility rule gives BYU "an unfair advantage over every other school in the country."

Most student-athletes have five years to complete four years of eligibility, but missionaries get seven.

Recent comments

It's amazing that people have the perception BYU has an advantage by...

DL Porter | June 20, 2009 at 11:10 a.m.

It is great to get committments of best recruits. It is another...

A "Blue" Bird in the Hand | June 19, 2009 at 6:51 p.m.

He wasn't sticking up for byu. He only hates the pub that the SEC...

re: 9:14 | June 19, 2009 at 9:06 a.m.

Image

Prized prep football recruits Zac Stout, left, Ross Apo and Jake Heaps will sign letters to attend BYU next year.

previousnext

Latest comments

So Cincinnati will be playing in the Sugar Bowl without a head coach. I...

Pitta doesn't win award

While I agree that it's ridiculous he didn't win, I don't think it has...

Officer kills Times Square scammer

To "what????" at 5:52 P.M., the original headline read: "Officer kills...

Knitting hearts together

I would love to know the directions on how to make the heart. Anyone know?

Cut and run business. Who's gonna pay for the roads, maintenance and...

BYU's Unga weighing his options

Collie is the real deal, and Payton Manning is the one saying it. Watch them...

Good article, good job Emery and Haws. JT is trying to impress the pro...

ATK to cut 800 jobs

Where is the Governor's Economic Bribery Council when you need it. Throw some...

Phoenix temple inspires thanks

Temples are frequently opposed. When the Denver Temple was built 21 year...

Obama can't 'create' jobs

Let see, the Chinese economy is growing, and most industry in that nation is...

Advertisements