Unlikely lobbyist takes on insurance

Published: Saturday, June 13, 2009 11:38 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

Diane Knight of Orem just got back from lobbying Congress in our nation's capital.

A preschool teacher by training, she never thought of herself as a lobbyist.

But then she never thought of herself as uninsurable either.

Diane's is one of those stories she was sure would never happen to her — until it happened to her.

It dates back nine years to the year 2000. The year began with Alan, Diane's husband, discovering he had cancer in his neck. Months later, Diane discovered she had breast cancer.

The couple battled like gladiators. He had dozens of lymph nodes and part of his neck muscles removed. She went through chemotherapy and radiation, lost her hair and underwent surgery.

Both came out the other end as cancer survivors.

That's when they began what Diane calls "our descent into the health insurance nightmare."

When Alan decided to leave the company he was working for to pursue a promising private-business enterprise, they discovered that because of their bouts with cancer, they would be largely uninsurable as individuals.

Only if one of them remained attached to a large company that provided insurance benefits could they stay insured at prices they could realistically afford.

Story continues below

Their solution was for Diane to shut down "Miss Diane's," the preschool she ran out of her home, and go to work as a teacher for the Alpine School District — not for the pay, the working conditions or because she wanted to.

For the insurance.

"When you're in a big company, you're invisible insurance-wise because the costs are spread out over a large number of people," explains Diane. "But if you're in a small company, just one person with a past can raise everybody's premiums to unhealthy levels."

And if you're trying to get individual insurance and you have "a past," forget about it.

"I loved being Miss Diane. I loved my preschool. I loved being a stay-at-home mom. But I had to shut my doors because of health insurance," she says. "I fail to see why health insurance can dictate what I do for a living. But it does. Health insurance runs my life."

People at the Utah Health Policy Project, a nonprofit group pushing for health insurance reform, heard Diane's story and got her in touch with Consumers Union, a national group with a similar agenda.

When Consumers Union — the parent company of Consumer Reports — organized an event called "Lobby Day" this past Wednesday, Diane was one of the people they flew to Washington, D.C., and trotted in front of members of Congress to tell her sad but true story.

"It was a really good experience," says Diane. "I feel like people really listened to what I had to say.

Recent comments

I am uninsurable because I have arthritis. I was fortunate enough to...

Underinsured | June 15, 2009 at 12:37 p.m.

People in this country are nieve about what Obama is trying to do and...

annoymous | June 14, 2009 at 8:30 p.m.

My youngest daughter was born with a severe physical condition that...

Lowell | June 14, 2009 at 10:45 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Okla. Mormons win Catholic trivia night

going to private schools is not so much about money as prioritization. BYU...

I am so sorry about what has happened. I know the greater the sorrow the...

Mormon chaplain honored in North Dakota

Chaplains of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints wear crosses....

Protests against Phoenix LDS temple

Most of the concerns voiced here are not valid, and they are clearly voiced...

The "general welfare" clause applies to the daily functioning of the United...

Letters: Trump card for believers

There are far more athiest/agnostics than Mormons in America and the...

Shut it down. Plain and simple.

Please, please, please - GIVE IT A REST! Your whining and constant...

Letters: Global warming a plot

I do not know if there is gobal warming or not. I think that is the wrong...

Letters: Trump card for believers

"Non-religious shoving their beliefs down the throats of the rest of us?"...

Advertisements