Family wins in train death lawsuit

Published: Wednesday, June 10, 2009 2:39 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

NEPHI — More than 11 years after 38-year-old Shelly Elder was struck and killed by a train he never saw coming, his family can find some relief knowing he was not at fault.

A jury recently awarded at least $250,000 in damages to Elder's widow, Nan, and his four children after finding the city of Nephi 70 percent negligent for failing to cut down trees that blocked Elder's view of the oncoming train, said attorney Allen Young.

The jury found unnamed parties 30 percent responsible, with Elder bearing no responsibility in the fatal crash.

"They were elated," Young said of the family. "Eight jurors found that their father and husband had … no fault in his own death, which we believed all along."

Elder was driving a dump truck across the train tracks at 300 West and Center Street in Nephi on May 27, 1998, at 8:15 a.m., when a Union Pacific train smashed into his driver's side door.

The train conductor testified that Elder had been looking north and failed to see the northbound train approaching from the south.

Young said even though Elder probably looked south, as well, seeing the train would have been nearly impossible, due to the large clump of 30-foot-tall trees growing out of an irrigation ditch.

The Elder family's lawsuit alleged the city of Nephi was negligent for failing to remove the trees.

Story continues below

The family also originally tried to sue Union Pacific, but that case was dismissed, as the trees weren't on railroad land, Young said.

There is still only a stop sign in the area, he said, with no flashing lights or wooden "arm" to prevent passage onto the tracks. However, the trees were cut down shortly after Elder's death.

The jury spent three hours deliberating after the five-day case before returning with their 70-percent-responsible verdict against the city.

However, under Utah law, because the unnamed parties, which could include the irrigation company, were less than 40 percent responsible, the court will enter judgment against Nephi for 100 percent of the damages, Young said. That doesn't mean a 30 percent increase in damages, however, due to financial caps.

Young said the parties had agreed to damages that exceeded $1 million, if the family won, but the financial caps could prevent the family from getting any more than $250,000.

E-mail: sisraelsen@desnews.com

Recent comments

I think a $250,000 cap is obscene. For many people that's less than 5...

Ron | June 11, 2009 at 12:17 p.m.

So after 11 years they are still getting the shaft. They should haen...

Boise/Pam | June 10, 2009 at 10:00 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

We love you and will keep your family in our prayers. May the Lord bless you...

I want to know why it is "going to the children" Should it not be going back...

Technical education includes only the skills that are defined by industry as...

Celtics crush Jazz

The Jazz need a trade ASAP to create some sort of spark.

I can apperciate that post, but with 2 -7 footers under the rim you are only...

Man i cant wait till saturday.. This is going to be a great game.. I hope...

5A teams best of decade

Hello, I'm a senior at Alta and I know it will be a tough battle with...

Lou Dobbs resigns from CNN

Fox has a credibility issue with middle America as being to far right winged....

I don't like the elbow being thrown. I have never played competitive soccer...

Cindy and family, We are so sad for your family's loss. You are in our...

Advertisements
Advertisement