Review mean-spirited

Published: Monday, June 1, 2009 12:17 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

I attended the same performance of Leonard Bernstein's "Mass" on May 29 as did critic Scott Iwasaki. And I would respectfully request that he never again be assigned to review any concert that is not rock or popular in content. His review was rife with factual errors. This piece was premiered in 1971, thus making it nearly 40 years old, not 30. A Mass is very seldom a symphony, as Mr. Iwasaki called it. It was actually subtitled "Theater Piece for Singers, Players and Dancers" by Bernstein himself. Denigrating Keith Lockhart's choice of this as his final performance because of its theatricality is somewhat mean-spirited, and certainly not necessary.

I have wanted to hear this piece in person for more than 30 years. It was a rare treat to have it in Salt Lake City. While not perfectly performed, it was a fine performance that deserved a far more even-handed review.

Sandefur Schmidt

Provo

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

High school players commit to BYU

And we all know that Rivals is the source we should all turn to for pure...

Lacking in chemistry, wit, and direction, "Past Life" is missing everything...

High school players commit to BYU

Congratulations.

Cedar Mountain wants high level waste disposal in a lake bed. Putting this...

Gosh guys, lighten up. So Palin wrote some notes on her hand and Gibbs poked...

UNLV bombs BYU into loss

We need to all be a bit more honest with ourselves and understand that we are...

Teachers, there's many of us that don't buy the scapegoating and think the...

Teacher merit pay debated

"Former Principal", I'm a Current Teacher and a member of my district's...

Why just minors?

Don't know about the rest of you posting here but I give a speech I sometimes...

Advertisements