Americans want democracy but can be apathetic

Published: Wednesday, May 27, 2009 9:55 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

The new Jordan School District gave me a chuckle the other day. Faced with some difficult budget decisions brought on by problems they didn't create, members of the new school board commissioned an opinion poll to get some advice.

The public, filled with the sage wisdom one can find only in a pure and direct democracy, said, essentially, Don't raise taxes, don't increase class sizes, and for heaven's sake, don't cut any of the programs we like.

Well, what were you expecting them to say? Modern Americans seem to have an obsession with a form of democracy that goes beyond the mere right to choose qualified representatives. That's quite different from what the nation's founders envisioned (the only political office they wanted to be chosen democratically is that of a representative in the House). It's also dangerous. Which brings me to California.

Although it hardly caused a ripple in the pond of Utah news last week, California held an election on Tuesday. Because things voters consider there sometimes cause sonic booms here (Prop. 8, anyone?), this one could eventually hit Utahns, too.

Story continues below

But then, it could hit all Americans. California is going bankrupt and, given the trend in recent months, it isn't too far-fetched to believe President Barack Obama and Congress will want to bail them out. You can't have a state that large falling into chaos and anarchy, after all. But bailing them out would require taking a bit of money from you and every other American. And yet it's interesting to note that an election touted as necessary to keep Californians from "financial Armageddon," as Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger put it, attracted only a smattering of voters. Official turnout figures weren't available yet as I wrote this, but reports told of hardly anyone showing up at polls.

Maybe they figured, as Californian Melissa Fazli told CNN, that they already had elected a bunch of super smart politicians (at least that's what they all said before the election, right?) to make the tough decisions. "It's just not right," she said to CNN. "We voted these people in in order to stand up for us and make the decisions that needed to be made, and they dropped the ball. And they just passed it on to us."

Recent comments

@Naruto: your take on democracy vs. capitalism is totally...

Earl | May 27, 2009 at 12:11 p.m.

Although the authorship of the following paragraphs is subject to...

No Free Lunch | May 27, 2009 at 12:03 p.m.

America is no longer a Democracy, it is purely Capitalism. In other...

Naruto | May 27, 2009 at 11:14 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

How true!! There is a gap and there is also a challenge to live like we should.

Interesting. A bill where Utahns agree with the major elements, but not the...

push poll. The questions are designed to elict a certain response. Sort of...

Beware delusions on climate

The air over any city in the world is filthy and killing us. The oceans are...

Re-creating Bethlehem

(Alma 7:10)says Jesus was born in Jerusalem?

It was a great event I'm glad to have been there. He has always been a great...

Utahns want health care reform bills

"just keep on talking" = "we can't afford to do nothing" Duh

USU home-court streak ends

Well there is one team that won't be coming back to the Spectrum!

Here is the progress of society to date: anyone can write a letter or post on...

Utahns want health care reform bills

A little off-topic, but your analogy is pretty close to the way our food IS...

Advertisements